3 Mills Surr. 528 | N.Y. Sur. Ct. | 1903
The decedent was, at the time of his death, engaged in carrying on business under the firm name of R. G. Dun & Co. The appraiser designated under the Tax Law included- in his appraisal the “ good-will of the business of the firm of R. G. Dun & Company, $2,000,000,” and the tax was fixed on this basis by an order of a surrogate. The executor appealed from that order. In my previous memorandum (39 Misc. Rep. 617), I stated that, upon the authority of the decision of the Appellate Division in this department in Matter of Heilman (77 App. Div. 355), the definition of “ personal estate ” or “ personal property ” contained in subdivision 4 of section 2 of the Tax Law must control, and I therefore determined that the good-will of the business was improperly included in the appraisal.
An appeal to the Court of Appeals was then pending, and both of the parties to the proceeding deemed it expedient to
As defined by the Statutory Construction Law (L. 1892, chap. 677, § 4), the term “ personal property” includes 41 everything, except real property, which may be the subject of ownership” (Matter of Jones, 172 N. Y. 575, 585).
The good-will of the business of the decedent is a right, exclusive in him and in those to whom he has given it by his will, to continue that business under the name used by him. It is clearly a thing capable of being the subject of ownership, and it is stipulated to have a large value. It is, therefore, property; its value was properly included in the appraisal, and the order appealed from must, in this respect, be affirmed.
The omission to tax the remainder interests was, under Matter of Vanderbilt (172 N. Y. 69), and Matter of Brez (id. 609), reported subsequent to the order, erroneous. The order will, as to this, be reversed, and the tax will be imposed on such remainders pursuant to the supplemental report of the appraiser made pending this appeal.
Order affirmed in respect to good will and reversed as to remainder interests.
