23 Haw. 46 | Haw. | 1915
OPINION OF THE COURT BY
These are appeals from the tax appeal court of the third judicial circuit making assessments as of January 1, 1915, the appellant in each case being the tax payer.
Hawi Mill & Plantation Co., Ltd. In this case the company returned the aggregate value of its combined property as the basis of an enterprise for profit at $550,000. The assessor assessed it at $1,000,000, and the tax appeal court fixed the valuation at $900,000. The matter of the assessment of this company’s plantation was before this court upon its 1912 assessment, and a valuation of $1,100,000 was then given it. Hawi M. & P. Co. v. Forrest, 21 Haw. 389. The company holds its lands partly in fee simple and partly under lease. About one-half of its cane area is artificially irrigated. Counsel for the appellant urges that the full cash value of the property was materially less on January 1, 1915, than it was three years previously and argues that the value of the plantation, as shown by the evidence, does not exceed $650,000.
As to the valuation of the separate items of property going to make up the whole, the record shows the estimate made by the deputy assessor, $926,403, as against that of the company, $547,653.97, without any express finding on the point by the tax appeal court. Probably the decision appealed from was based largely upon the data which was submitted on behalf of the company showing its receipts, expenses and profits for seven years, coupled with such testimony as was offered showing changes in conditions since 1912, and the testimony of the assessor show
We hold that the assessment as fixed by the tax appeal court should not be disturbed. It is affirmed.
Union Mill Company. In this case the corporation returned the aggregate value of its plantation property as the basis of an enterprise for profit at $200,000. The assessor assessed it at $300,000, and the assessment was sustained by the tax appeal court.
This plantation adjoins that of the Hawi Mill & Plantation Co. in the district of North Kohala, and is subject to the same climatic conditions. Like the other plantation it is partly irrigated, and obtains its water supply from the same source, the Kohala ditch. Its cane lands comprise an area of about 1453 acres owned in fee simple, and 874 acres held under lease. It also has about 533 acres of pasture
We are of the opinion that the decision appealed from should be affirmed, and it is so ordered.