991 S.W.2d 507 | Tex. App. | 1999
OPINION
Opinion by
Relator, Claudia Sanchez, has filed an .application for writ of mandamus asking that we order the Respondent
In the first proceeding,
Thereafter, Sanchez took the depositions of Mike Bare, vice-president of operations; Lynn Scott, Daisy’s former vice-president of sales and marketing; and Ronald Joyce, the Daisy employee who designed the rifle model in question.
Sanchez asserts that once less intrusive methods have been utilized to obtain the information, she is no longer required to show that Griffin has unique or superior knowledge. We agree. The supreme court stated in Crown Cent. Petroleum Corp. v. Garda, 904 S.W.2d 125 (Tex.1995) (orig.proceeding), that after the requesting party makes a good faith effort to obtain the discovery through less intrusive methods, the party may move the court to lift the protective order by showing
(1) that there is a reasonable indication that the official’s deposition is calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, and (2) that the less intrusive methods of discovery are unsatisfactory, insufficient or inadequate. If the party seeking the deposition makes this showing, the trial court should modify or vacate the protective order as appropriate.... If the party seeking the deposition fails to make this showing, the trial court should leave the protective order in place.
Sanchez asserts that, after utilizing less intrusive methods, there remain unanswered forty-eight “areas of inquiry.” These “areas of inquiry” do not in any way relate to the details of the day-to-day operation of the Engineering, Design, Manufacturing or Marketing Departments.
We conclude that Sanchez has satisfied the two-prong Crown test by showing a reasonable indication that Griffin’s deposition will lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, and that the less intrusive methods of discovery were unsatisfactory, insufficient, or inadequate. Accordingly, we conditionally grant Sanchez’s request for mandamus relief. The mandamus will issue only if Respondent fails to lift the protective order.
. The Honorable Rogelio Valdez, Judge of the 357th Judicial District Court of Cameron County, Texas.
. In re Daisy Manufacturing Co., 976 S.W.2d 327 (Tex.App.—Corpus Christi 1998, orig. proceeding).
.Sanchez had previously propounded written discovery upon Daisy and had deposed its corporate representative, William Stuchlik.
. The "areas of inquiry” can be grouped into the following categories: company policy; design of the gravity feed system vs. design and implementation of a positive feed system; defects in the product; sales; net worth; comments Griffin made on a