126 Misc. 2d 197 | N.Y. Sup. Ct. | 1984
OPINION OF THE COURT
Does section 50-b of the Civil Rights Law permit a defendant, sued in a tort action arising out of a sexual assault for failing to provide adequate security upon the premises where the sexual assault took place, to inspect a New York City Police Department investigative report pertaining to the incident?
It appears that on May 4,1983, the infant plaintiff in the tort action was on a school trip to New York City and was assaulted and sexually molested by an individual at the premises owned by petitioner. A lawsuit was begun against the school district and petitioner. The allegations of negligence directed against the Rockefeller Center defendants are that they provided inadequate security to the public.
Rockefeller Center and its codefendant contend that it is necessary for them to obtain the Police Department’s investigation file and report in order to prepare a defense to the tort action.
The tort defendant Rockefeller Center (along with its codefendant Herricks Union Free School District) have persuaded me that they require an inspection of the Police Department’s investigative report in order to prepare their respective defense. They have properly made this application on notice to the parents of the infant plaintiff and all other parties set out in the statute (Civil Rights Law, § 50-b, subd 2, par b). They are “persons” within the meaning of the term used in the statute.
A succeeding subdivision (Civil Rights Law, § 50-b, subd 3) provides that “The court having jurisdiction over the alleged sex offense may order any restrictions upon disclosure authorized in subdivision two of this section, as it deems necessary and proper to preserve the confidentiality of the identity of the victim.” But, since the victim has chosen to sue in a civil action, there is no identity to keep from being disclosed. Nevertheless, the court, without first examining the contents of the file, should not permit blanket disclosure.
Accordingly, the respondent is directed to make copies of its investigative file kept and prepared in connection with the sexual assault made upon the infant plaintiff, available for inspection first by this court in chambers (room 554 at 111 Centre Street, New York, New York 10013) on November 15, 1984, at 3:00 p.m. After such inspection, counsel for the petitioner here may inspect and copy the file, as determined upon inspection by the court.