| N.Y. Sur. Ct. | Jan 15, 1912
There being some difficulty in the proof of this will in the ordinary or common form before the clerk, I directed the proofs to be retaken before me. The will is a holograph. Holographic testaments are doubtless favored in probate law. In the civil law even the signature of the testator to a holograph was dispensed with. C. 6, 23, 21, pr. Under our old law, prior to the last century, if it were certain that a testament was written or subscribed by the testator, the testimony of witnesses was unnecessary. Swinb. 639; Gilb. Rep. 260. But since our present Statute of Wills, while the evidence of publication of a holographic testament may be somewhat relaxed, nevertheless a substantial compliance with the statute is essential ; and both publication and rogatio testkim, or a request to the witnesses to act as attesting witnesses, must be made out in some way to entitle such a testmentary paper to probate as a will. Matter of Phillips, 98 N.Y. 267" court="NY" date_filed="1885-03-03" href="https://app.midpage.ai/document/in-re-to-revoke-the-probate-of-the-will-of-phillips-3599038?utm_source=webapp" opinion_id="3599038">98 N. Y. 267; Matter of Beckett, 103 id. 167; Matter of Hunt, 110 id. 278, 281; Matter of Turell, 166 id. 330; Matter of Moore, 109 A.D. 762" court="N.Y. App. Div." date_filed="1905-12-15" href="https://app.midpage.ai/document/in-re-proving-the-last-will--testament-of-moore-5197177?utm_source=webapp" opinion_id="5197177">109 App. Div. 762, 765; affd., 187 N.Y. 573" court="NY" date_filed="1907-02-19" href="https://app.midpage.ai/document/in-re-proving-the-will-of-moore-3615523?utm_source=webapp" opinion_id="3615523">187 N. Y. 573.
In this case both of the witnesses to the will of Mr. Wilmerding swear positively that there was no publication by the testator, and neither witness knew that the instrument which he subsigned was a will until long subsequently to the disruption of the session during which they so subsigned. As was intimated in substance in Matter of Moore, supra, it would be a dangerous practice to permit even a meritorious holograph to be established in defiance of the positive testimony of those
I am constrained to refuse probate to the paper propounded. Settle decree accordingly.
Probate denied.