101 F. 560 | E.D.N.C. | 1900
Some of the creditors of "J. W. Peacock, bankrupt, object to a final discharge on grounds set out as follows: First, because of false representations by the bankrupt when the debts were contracted, representing that another (his son) was a member of the firm; second, that notice of the dissolution of the firm was not given to creditors; third,such representations were made without the consent of said son; and, fourth, the bankrupt concealed his true financial condition when the goods were purchased and the debts contracted. These four grounds of objection in effect charge false representations which might amount to a criminal offense, but not
The fourth objection is that the bankrupt could not account for the proceeds of sale of goods sold; -and, fifth, that “a short while prior to filing his petition” he sold goods, and paid debts contracted several months prior thereto. The periods fixed by the bankruptcy law are definite and specific. Allegations fixing no time within which goods were sold, except by the phrases “a short while prior to-,” and “several months before,” are too indefinite and uncertain. They may mean hours, days, months, or years. They are no more definite than “some time before,” or the expressions with which all good nursery tales open, — of “once upon a time,” “in the good old days,” and other classic phrases with which mothers, nurses, and others mystify and amuse the young mind. In iEsop’s Fables, Grimm’s and other fairy tales, “Nights with Uncle Remus,” or, it may be, in equity proceedings when time is not of the essence of the contract, such expressions may be fit and proper; but in bankruptcy proceedings the periods within which certain acts must be done, or alleged to be done, are fixed by statute, and, unless done or alleged within the statutory periods, they are of no avail. Acts of bankruptcy, assignments or transfers, preferences,
Objections 4 and 5, while they may refer, or be intended to refer, to acts which might defeat the bankrupt’s discharge, are too indefinite in substance to serve that purpose. The objections are therefore overruled, and the bankrupt will be granted a final discharge.