In Re Memorial Estates, Inc., Debtor. Appeal of Cemco, Inc
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Posner
This appeal in a bankruptcy case requires us to decide two questions of surprising novelty: whether an order by a district judge appointing a receiver in a bankruptcy case is ever appealable even though it is not a final order, and, if so (for, if not, we cannot reach the issue on the merits), whether the law ever allows the appointment of a receiver in a bankruptcy case.
The principal asset of Memorial Estates, Inc. is a cemetery on which the Chicago Bank of Commerce has a mortgage for more than $400,000. Memorial defaulted on the loan secured by the mortgage. The bank began a foreclosure action in an Illinois state court and asked the judge to appoint a receiver to operate the cemetery until the action was over. Memorial had (without the bank’s consent) turned over the operation of the cemetery to Cerneo, Inc., which was busy selling cemetery plots and was keeping the proceeds. Cerneo took the position that the plots were not covered by the mortgage and hence that it owed the bank nothing. The bank vigorously disagreed, pointing out that if Cemco was right the only security for the mortgage was the part of the cemetery not actually usable for cemetery plots, mainly roads and paths, even though the mortgage instrument purported to secure the entire cemetery. The appointment of a receiver
After an evidentiary hearing the bankruptcy judge decided that a receiver for the cemetery should be appointed pending the foreclosure action, and he so recommended to the district judge, who agreed and appointed the receiver. The bankruptcy judge himself could not appoint the receiver, because the foreclosure suit was collateral to the bankruptcy — a “related” rather than “core” bankruptcy case — so that the actual rulings had to be made by the district judge, with the bankruptcy judge’s role being advisory. See
Cemco intervened in the district court to oppose the appointment of the receiver, and appeals from the appointment. A trustee has been appointed to liquidate Memorial, but he seems to be inactive pending outcome of the foreclosure action, which is proceeding in the district court while the receiver administers the cemetery. The trustee did not object to the appointment of the receiver.
1. If this were not a bankruptcy case there would be no doubt that the district judge’s order was appealable, because
Although no statute makes
Under the old law of bankruptcy appeals, moreover, any nontrivial order concerning the bankruptcy proceeding itself, as distinct from related matters (“controversies”), mainly disputes between creditors or (as here) between the debtor and a creditor, was appealable regardless of finality. See
In re Chicago, Milwaukee, St. Paul & Pac. R.R.,
756 F.2d 508, 511-13 (7th Cir.1985). Therefore an order appointing a bankruptcy receiver would clearly have been appeal-able when made. See
In re Homer Arth Well No. 1,
529 F.2d 1272, 1273-74 (6th Cir.1976) (order appointing trustee appeal-able). Although the distinction between proceedings and controversies has been abolished, see
Any need to make express provision in the new law (the Bankruptcy Code enacted in 1978) for appeals from orders appointing receivers in bankruptcy cases must have seemed eliminated by
The key to the issue of appealability in the present case, however, is the distinction noted earlier between an equity receiver and a bankruptcy receiver. When the bank moved in state court for the appointment of a receiver, it was not asking for the appointment of a bankruptcy receiver; the case was not a bankruptcy case (and the state courts do not have bankruptcy jurisdiction, see
We hold that
The result is not an entirely comfortable one; if the cases cited earlier that hold unappealable the appointment of a trustee in bankruptcy are correct, it is not obvious why the appointment of a receiver should be appealable. But that is a complaint to take up with Congress, which made the appointment of equity receivers appealable regardless of finality; the receiver appointed in this case was an equity receiver. The distinction in appealability is not entirely arbitrary, moreover, since the appointment of the trustee in bankruptcy is hedged about with various procedural safeguards (which may reduce the probability of error), and the appointment of an equity receiver is not.
2. Our analysis of jurisdiction shows not only that the order that Cemco complained of is appealable but also that, contrary to Cemco’s submission, the district court had the power to appoint the receiver. Additional support for this conclusion is found in decisions authorizing the appointment of receivers in civil enforcement proceedings by the Securities and Exchange Commission, even though the defendant is in bankruptcy. See, e.g., SEC v. First Financial Group of Texas, 645 F.2d 429, 439-40 (5th Cir.1981); SEC v. Lincoln Thrift Ass’n, 577 F.2d 600, 605-08 (9th Cir.1978).
The power cut off by
Cemco can, however, complain about the appointment of the receiver to the extent that that appointment improper
The appointment of the receiver is affirmed. The other orders from which Cern-eo attempts to appeal are clearly nonfinal, and not within any statutory or judge-made exception to the rule that only final orders by district courts may be appealed to this court; so the appeals from those orders are dismissed.
So Ordered.