In re McConnell
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Ray
In 1902, the bankrupt, Joseph A. McConnell, who is a cousin of said Eliza Carr, had noticed a vacant lot in the city of Watertown which was for sale. He conceived the idea that money could be made by purchasing same and dividing it up into building lots and reselling. He did not have the money with which to purchase. McConnell thereupon went to Eliza Carr and informed her that in his judgment money could be made by purchasing the tract and that it could be divided up into three lots and sold in his opinion for $700 each, and that the property could be purchased for $1,400. He also informed Miss Carr that he did not have the money and that if she would furnish the money they would buy the property together; that he would look after the business part of the transaction and procure purchasers and attend to the sale; and that when the lots were sold they would divide the profits. Miss Carr had money in the Savings Bank and so informed McConnell. She inquired of him what security she would have for the money she was advancing to purchase his share, and he informed her that he would give her a note, and that the note would be evidence as to his actual interest in the property. Miss Carr inquired if that would be suf*440ficient to protect her, and McConnell informed her that it would be,, and that if at any time she wanted further security he would give her a mortgage on his interest in the property. McConnell’ further stated to Miss Carr that when the property was sold she should first be paid the $1,400 she was to advance. Miss Carr consented to this-arrangement and advanced the $1,400, which was used to pay for the property, and a deed was taken to said McConnell and Miss Carr and recorded in the Jefferson county clerk’s office. McConnell gave to-Miss Carr his promissory note for $700 payable on demand at 3 per cent, interest. It was understood that this low rate of interest should offset the labor performed by McConnell in managing the business- and selling the property. Both understood that the purchase was a speculation. They bore the burdens of the purchase in the manner stated and were to share the profits as stated. McConnell was a lawyer of standing and reputation, while Miss Carr was a lady of but little financial business experience. It was not contemplated that any building or structure should be erected on the lots, but .that they should be sold at a profit, if possible. McConnell was supposed to be of ample financial responsibility. Miss Carr never demanded a mortgage as security. McConnell went into bankruptcy, and a partition^, suit was started; but this was stayed by this court.
“Persons who jointly purchase land to hold it for a rise in value are not partners, but are tenants in common, and either party can .sue the other at law for reimbursement of allowances made by him on the joint account without there first having been a final settlement and the. striking of a balance.”
This case is cited, approved, and followed in Miller v. Ahrens (C. C.) 163 Fed. 870, 875. See, also, Pillsbury v. Pillsbury, 20 N. H. 90, Farrand v. Gleason, 56 Vt. 633, and Winslow v. Young, 94 Me. 145, 160, 47 Atl. 149, to the same effect.
If two persons purchase real estate and take the deed to themselves as tenants in common, and one pays nine-tenths of the purchase money and the other one-tenth, and it is orally agreed that when the property is sold the one shall have nine-tenths of the proceeds and the other one-tenth, can it be that, in the absence of a bona fide purchaser for value or liens, the agreement is not enforceable, and that the tenant in common who put in the nine-tenths of the purchase money may not claim it when a sale is made ? I think not. If Miss Carr had loaned the $700 to McConnell out and out and taken his note as evidence of the debt, the case would be different. True, she took his note for $700, but not as evidence of a simple loan or debt. True, she let McConnell have not alone $700, but $1,400, with which to purchase this real estate and take a deed in their names. However, the transaction and agreement was that when the property was sold Miss Carr was first to have her $1,400 out of the proceeds with 3 per cent, interest added on $700 and her share of the increase in value, if any. This’ represented her interest in this property as one of the two tenants in common. If it should sell “for more than $1,400, McConnell had an interest to the extent of one-half of such surplus. If it should not sell for more, he had no interest.
“Where a conveyance to purchasers of a tenancy In common is silent as to the interest of each, such interests are ordinarily presumed to be equal. But such presumption is rebuttable. There is a presumption that purchasers of a common estate hold shares therein in proportion to their contribution to the purchase price, if the contributions to. the purchase price be shown to have been unequal; but, if the deed to purchasers does not show their respective interests in the common property, the presumption arising from the deed may be overcome by the presumption arising from the amount of contribution.” Bittle v. Clement, supra.
There will be a decree accordingly.