In re L.Z.
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Suttell, Goldberg, Robinson, Lynch Prata, Long
O R D E R
This order concerns two consolidated appeals that came before the Supreme Court pursuant to an order directing the parties to appear and show cause why the issues raised should not be summarily decided. On appeal, the respondent, L.Z., challenges orders granting petitions for civil certification and instructions. The respondent asserts that the hearing judges erred in finding, by clear and convincing evidence, that she was unable to care for herself and conduct her own affairs and that she posed a risk of harm to herself or others, among other things, and that these matters are not moot because they are capable of repetition yet evade review.1 After considering the parties’ written and oral submissions and reviewing the record, we conclude that cause has not been shown and that these cases may be decided without further briefing or argument. For the reasons set forth herein, we dismiss the appeals.
The respondent contends that these matters should be addressed by this Court, even if moot, because they raise questions of important public policy that are capable of repetition yet will evade review. The respondent further asserts that the hearing judges erred in granting the motion of respondent’s attorney to withdraw and denying respondent’s motion for new counsel; in denying respondent’s motion for a continuance; and in denying respondent’s objection to testimony based on hearsay, thereby violating her constitutional and statutory right to cross-examine witnesses. Finally, respondent contends that the hearing judges erred in finding by clear and convincing evidence that she was unable to care for herself and conduct her own affairs and that she posed a risk of harm to herself or others.
This Court has consistently held that “a case is moot if the original complaint raised a justiciable controversy, but events occurring after the filing have deprived the litigant of a continuing stake in the controversy.” Rhode Island Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals v. L.Z., 208 A.3d 242, 242-43 (R.I. 2019) (mem.) (quoting Hallsmith-Sysco Food Services, LLC v. Marques, 970 A.2d 1211, 1213 (R.I. 2009)).
When the appeal from the first order was docketed with this Court on February 8, 2022, the District Court no longer retained jurisdiction to amend or extend the original order appealed from, which expired by its own terms on February 28, 2022. See Thompson v. Thompson, 973 A.2d 499, 513 (R.I. 2009) (“It is well established that once an appeal has been docketed in this Court, the lower court no longer has jurisdiction.”). Further, the order appealed from in the second case expired on February 28, 2023. It is undisputed that the orders appealed from have
The nature of these civil certification cases presents a unique challenge for ensuring that justice is carried out in the face of the fast-approaching mootness deadline, which looms over the cases and often prevents them from being heard on appeal. We are hopeful that respondent remains on her current path as it has been represented that she is no longer being medicated, is cooperating with the Providence Center and has been living in a “supervised apartment.”3 In the unfortunate circumstance that a similar petition is filed against respondent in the future, we direct petitioner, the Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals (BHDDH), to ensure that a stenographer is provided for any hearing. Furthermore, we deem it necessary for respondent to have, at least, standby counsel in these hearings going forward.
We are mindful of the arguments made by the respondent’s counsel with respect to the hearings in these matters, particularly as to the absence of the doctor who signed the petition, as well as BHDDH bearing the burden of proof. See
Accordingly, we dismiss the appeals.
Entered as an Order of this Court this 8th day of June, 2023.
By Order,
/s/ Debra A. Saunders, Clerk
Clerk
ORDER COVER SHEET
| Title of Case | In re L.Z. |
| Case Number | No. 2022-41-Appeal. (MH-21-341) No. 2022-278-Appeal. (MH-22-257) |
| Date Order Filed | June 8, 2023 |
| Justices | Suttell, C.J., Goldberg, Robinson, Lynch Prata, and Long, JJ. |
| Source of Appeal | Sixth Division District Court |
| Judicial Officer from Lower Court | Associate Judge Pamela Woodcock-Pfeiffer Associate Judge James J. Caruolo |
| Attorney(s) on Appeal | For Petitioner: Thomas J. Corrigan, Jr. Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals For Respondent: George J. West, Esq. |
SU-CMS-02B (revised November 2022)