In Re Garcia
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Pusateri
MEMORANDUM OF DECISION
JAMES A. PUSATERI, Bankruptcy Judge.The debtors filed a Chapter 13 plan on February 19,1980. A creditor, General Motors Acceptance Corporation, objected to confirmation of the debtors’ plan on March 18, 1980. A hearing on confirmation and the objection thereto was held on April 4, 1980.
The creditor argued that the debtors’ plan is violative of
The debtors contend that their plan complies with the applicable-provisions of Title 11 U.S.C. and should be confirmed.
The parties were given the opportunity to argue and brief the issues involved and the case is now ready for decision.
FINDINGS OF FACT
The debtors filed a Chapter 13 plan on February 19, 1980. The plan proposed to pay secured creditors the value of their security as long as the creditor’s lien was valid. Unsecured creditors were divided into three classes. Cosigned unsecured debts were to be paid in full. An attorney representing the debtors in an ongoing lawsuit was to be paid in full. All other unsecured creditors were to receive what they would receive in a Chapter 7 liquidation. Unsecured creditors would receive nothing in a Chapter 7 liquidation.
General Motors Acceptance Corporation (GMAC) is a creditor with a claim in excess of $36,000 in this proceeding. GMAC’s claim is partially secured, the collateral having been valued in the debtors’ plan at $22,000. GMAC, on March 18, 1980, objected to the debtors’ plan on the basis that the plan was not proposed in good faith [
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The creditor presented no evidence that the debtors’ plan pays less than would be received by creditors in a Chapter 7 liquidation. The schedules which are a part of the debtors’ plan reflect that general creditors would receive nothing in a Chapter 7 liquidation. The Court therefore concludes that the creditor has failed in this portion of its objection to confirmation.
Initially, the creditor’s objection on this point was that the debtors’ plan called for no specific percentage payment to general creditors and was thus violative of
The creditor cites several cases to the Court which stand for the proposition that some percentage of total unsecured debt must be paid to all creditors or confirmation is to be denied on the basis of lack of good faith pursuant to
The Court has reviewed those cases and others.
Matter of Marlow,
3 B.R. 305, 1 C.B.C.2d 705 (Bkrtcy.) held that good faith is to be equated with the making of a “meaningful” payment. The word “meaningful” is not defined nor is it stated to whom or to what percent of to whom the payment must be meaningful.
In Re Beaver,
2 B.R. 337, 1 C.B.C.2d 609 (Bkrtcy.) also equates good faith with meaningful payment. In
Beaver
the debtor was said to be paying all she could or possibly more than she should but she was denied confirmation because her plan lacked good faith.
In Re Iacavoni, 2
B.R. 256, 1 C.B.C.2d 331 (Bkrtcy.) defines good faith as less than a debtor’s best effort and to be equated with a meaningful payment.
Iacavoni
also suggests some criteria which may vary with each case.
In Re Campbell,
3 B.R. 57, 1 C.B.C.2d 653 (Bkrtcy.) equates good faith with “substantial” payment rather than “meaningful” payment. “Substantial” is not defined other than to say that the facts of each case must be considered.
In Re Burrell,
2 B.R. 650, 1 C.B.C.2d 474 (Bkrtcy.) imputes requirements of best effort and substantial payment into
*38 The Court gathers from the above cases and others of similar reasoning that in order to be safe a debtor must propose a plan which pays creditors at least 70%, is the debtor’s best effort and is thought to be such as well as meaningful by all interested parties as well as the judge. The Court, however, finds no support for requiring a 70% payment or any other specific percent payment from a debtor in a composition plan either in the Code or its predecessor. Furthermore, the terms “substantial” and “meaningful” are not definitive terms, have resulted in diverse judgments and are nowhere to be found in the Code as requirements for confirmation. Certainly good faith was not so defined by Congress. It did not supply any definition for that term either in the Code or the Legislative History-
The Court can think of nothing more disheartening and frustrating to a debtor in this type of proceeding than to be told that he or she has met the standards expressly set forth in
It is the conclusion of this Court that confirmation of a debtor’s plan must be governed by
The foregoing constitutes Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law under Bankruptcy Rule 752 and