In re Expunction R.P.
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Palafox
El Paso County Sheriff‘s Office, El Paso County Attorney‘s Office, El Paso County Clerk‘s Office, District Attorney‘s Office, District Clerk‘s Office, Records Management and Archives, West Texas Community Supervision and Corrections Department (Probation), El Paso County Court Administration and the Jail Magistrate (collectively referred to as the County) appeal an order of expunction in favor of R.P. which addresses two misdemeanor charges that stem from an arrest that additionally led to a felony charge for aggravated kidnapping. In a single issue, the County argues that R.P. failed to prove that his multi-charge arrest did not result in a term of court-imposed community supervision due to the felony charge of aggravated kidnapping. The County asserts that R.P. is not entitled to expunge some charges while retaining another when all charges stem from a single arrest. Finding error, we reverse and render.
R.P. filed a petition to expunge all criminal records and files relating to two misdemeanor charges-i.e., for unlawful restraint and assault causing bodily injury to a family member-with both charges stemming from his arrest on September 10, 2011. In response, the County filed a general denial. When the trial court held an evidentiary hearing, R.P. testified but no other evidence was admitted by the court.1 R.P. testified that he was arrested on September 10, 2011, on suspicion of unlawful restraint and assault causing bodily injury to a family member. Both allegations were subsequently charged under cause numbers 20110C08744 and 20120C09023 and assigned to county courts of El Paso County. He further testified that both cases were subsequently dismissed, and he served no community supervision probation on either case. R.P. additionally testified that he had not been convicted of any felony in any other cause arising out of a subsequent incident.
On cross-examination, R.P. confirmed that his two misdemeanor charges were re-indicted as aggravated kidnapping and the charge was related to the same incident and arrest. He testified that he was not convicted of any felony. Next, he was asked the following questions:
[County Attorney]: Did you plea guilty to aggravated kidnapping? Did you plea guilty to that charge?
[R.P.]: I don‘t know.
[County Attorney]: Okay. Do you know whether or not you received deferred adjudication for that charge?
[R.P.]: Yes, sir. [Emphasis added.]
Shortly thereafter, the trial court entered an order granting R.P.‘s petition. This appeal followed.2
DISCUSSION
Standard of Review
A trial court‘s ruling on a petition for expunction is reviewed for an abuse of discretion. State v. T.S.N. ,
Applicable Law
Article 55.01(a) of the Code of Criminal Procedure governs a petitioner‘s right to expunction and provides, in relevant part:
(a) A person who has been placed under a custodial or noncustodial arrest for commission of either a felonyor misdemeanor is entitled to have all records and files relating to the arrest expunged if:
. . .
(2) the person has been released and the charge, if any, has not resulted in a final conviction and is no longer pending and there was no court-ordered community supervision under Chapter 42A for the offense, unless the offense is a Class C misdemeanor, provided that:
(A) regardless of whether any statute of limitations exists for the offense and whether any limitations period for the offense has expired, an indictment or information charging the person with the commission of a misdemeanor offense based on the person‘s arrest or charging the person with the commission of any felony offense arising out of the same transaction for which the person was arrested:
(i) has not been presented against the person at any time following the arrest....
Act effective January 1, 2017, 84th Leg., R.S., ch. 770 (H.B. 2299), § 2.23,
The right to an expunction of records is a statutory right. In re A.G. ,
Recently, in State v. T.S.N. , the Texas Supreme Court expressly recognized that article 55.01, when viewed as a whole, is neither entirely arrest-based nor offense-based given that prerequisites required by subsections (a)(1) and (a)(2) are quite different. T.S.N. ,
Regarding subsection (a)(2), this Court and several other Texas courts have reasoned
Analysis
Here, because the County filed its general denial, R.P. thus bore the burden of proof to show that he met all statutory requirements of the expunction scheme. G.B.E. ,
Statutory provisions require R.P. to show that the charge for which expunction is sought has not resulted in court-ordered community supervision, nor has an indictment charging the person with a felony offense arisen “out of the same transaction for which the person was arrested[.]” TEX. CODE CRIM. PROC. ANN. art. 55.01(a)(2)(A). We find that R.P.‘s failure to establish the elements of the expunction statute for his aggravated kidnapping charge thereafter disqualifies him from receiving an expunction of the other offenses relating to the arrest of September 10, 2011. See Ex parte Burton ,
Furthermore, R.P. testified that the indictment for aggravated kidnapping arose from the same incident and arrest as the two misdemeanor offenses for which he seeks expunction. Aggravated kidnapping is a felony offense. See TEX. PENAL CODE ANN . § 20.04. Under subsection (a)(2)(A)(i), a petitioner is disqualified from receiving an expunction if he fails to show that no felony offense arising out of the same transaction for which he was arrested has been presented against him at any time following the arrest. TEX. CODE CRIM. PROC. ANN . art. 55.01(a)(2)(A)(i). Thus, R.P.‘s indictment for a felony offense arising out of the same transaction for the misdemeanors on which he was arrested precludes a grant of expunction on those misdemeanors. See Ex parte Brown ,
For the above reasons, we conclude that R.P. has failed to strictly satisfy the requirements of the expunction statute, and the trial court had no power to grant expunction of the records for the offenses of unlawful restraint and assault causing bodily injury to a family member. See In re A.G. ,
CONCLUSION
We reverse and render judgment denying expunction on R.P.‘s offenses of unlawful restraint and assault causing bodily injury to a family member.
Notes
After completing its cross-examination of R.P., the County started to mention it had exhibits it wanted to admit but the court instructed counsel to wait and allow R.P.‘s counsel to speak. After R.P.‘s counsel finished his argument, the County responded with its counter-argument. The trial court then granted R.P.‘s petition and closed the hearing without the County having an opportunity to submit any documents.
This case was submitted on the County‘s brief only without R.P. filing a responsive brief.