2 Barb. Ch. 208 | New York Court of Chancery | 1847
I have duly considered this petition, and have examined and conversed with the petitioner for the purpose of ascertaining the state of his mind. And I am satisfied his mind is so far restored as to enable him to dispose of his estate by will with sense and judgment; provided he is allowed to do so under the superintendence of some proper officer of the court, to guard him against the immediate exercise of any undue or improper influence. It also appears, from the petitioner’s statements as to the situation of Ms family connections, that all his personal estate; in case of Ms death without a will, would go to the surviving brother and sister of his deceased mother, as his next of kin; one of whom is a man of great wealth. And there are a great number of first cousins of the petitioner, the children of deceased brothers and sisters of his mother; some of which cousins, as he states, have peculiar claims upon his bounty, on account of the kindness and care which then deceased parents bestowed upon him when he was in a situation to need it. But as the statute of distributions, in this state, does not allow of representation among collateral relatives of the decedent, beyond nephews and nieces, none of his cousins will be entitled to share in his personal estate, if he should die in the lifetime either of his uncle or of his aunt. Although such an event is very improbable, he should unquestionably be permitted to make a will, disposing of -his estate
. I think the general state -of -his mind has greatly improved since the -finding of the inquisition, in this matter, more than two years since. -And if a commission were to be issued against him, at this time, he -would not, probably, be fo.und to be a person of-unsound mind. But -as his mental powers are not yet ftilly restored to their original strength and vigor, -it might not be a-discreet exercise of the power-of the court now to discharge" his committee, and restore him to the entire control of his property, and thereby to leave him exposed to the arts and. devices of thpse who might be disposed to take advantage of ■the weakness of his mind, to defraud him of his estate.
The only-question in this case is as to the power of this court to suspend the operation of the commission, and of the inquisition, so far as to -allow him to make a testamentary disposition of -his property, -without' discharging the proceedings against him entirely, and restoring him to the full control of -his estate for every purpose. But Upon -a careful examination -of the ■question, I -think the court-has the -power to-discharge the proceedings -against him partially; retaining the control of his property so far only-as may he deemed necessary to protect the same for his benefit. This -has frequently been done by the court in -the case "of habitual drunkards, who had been found incapable of governing themselves -and managing their property, and who were actually -endeavoring to abandon their former degrading -habits; but who had not yet so far overcome the cravings of their diseased appetites as to render it safe to ■ put their ¡property wholly -under their control. The case under ■consideration-is similar -in principle; although- the petitioner’s original incompetency did -not arise entirely -from his indulgence -in the use -of intoxicating liquors, but was produced, in a..great me"astire¡-by other causes, which-are now removed.
.'I shall therefore -direct an order to -be entered, to -discharge the petitioner from the commission :and inquisition,.-and -from the control of the committees of -his person and of-his estate, ..so far as to permit him to make a will under the advice and
Such an order will of course be without prejudice to the rights of the petitioner’s heirs at law, or next of kin, to contest the validity of his will, if he should make one, and should die leaving it unrevoked. The sole, object of the order being to remove the technical objection, that a person who has been found by inquisition to be incapable-of governing himself and managing his affairs, is legally incompetent to make a valid will, while his person and property are .under the control of the committee appointed by the court.