Huston v. TribbettsHuston v. Tribbetts
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Cartwright
delivered the opinion of the court:
Appellee has a life estate in a tract of land of one hundred and sixty acres, and appellant owns the remainder in fee. The land is worth $8000, and in 1893 it was specially assessed for benefits in the construction of a ditch
No objection is made to the form of the judgment or the direction of the Appellate Court if the defense set up by the special plea was a good one, and for the purpose
It is not doubted that appellee, as the owner of the life estate, must pay the annual taxes assessed against the property. They are imposed as a yearly burden for’ the current benefits derived from the administration of the laws, the protection of property and the general welfare. Special assessments like this, although levied through the exercise of the taxing power, are not regarded as such ordinary taxes, but as an equivalent for benefits in the increased value of the property. (Cooley on Taxation, 416; Canal Trustees v. City of Chicago, 12 Ill. 403; County of McLean v. City of Bloomington, 106 id. 209; Illinois Central Railroad Co. v. City of Decatur, 126 id. 92.) The benefits for which ordinary taxes are exacted are realized from year to year, and it is just that the owner of the life estate should pay them, but they rest upon entirely different grounds from a special assessment, where the improvement is a permanent benefit to the property and to the remainder. Where the whole estate is benefited by the discharge of an encumbrance it is to be apportioned ratably between the tenant for life and the remainder-man. (4 Kent’s Com. 74; 6 Am. & Eng. Ency. of Law, 882.) Upon that principle it is held that the life tenant and remainder-man are chargeable with their several portions of special assessments beneficial to each. Peck v. Sherwood, 56 N.Y. 615; Plympton v. Boston Dispensary, 106 Mass. 546; Carns v. Chobert, 3 Edw. Ch. 312.
The argument for appellant is grounded on the claim that a contrary rule was laid down in Warren v. Warren, 148 Ill. 641, and that it was there held that the life tenant must pay and discharge all special assessments. In that case Alva Warren by his will appointed his son, John H. Warren, trustee of his estate, and directed him to pay
The circuit court erred in sustaining the demurrer to the special plea, and the judgment of the Appellate Court will be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.