Humphrey v. ArgravesHumphrey v. Argraves
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Daly
The plaintiffs appealed to the Superior Court from an appraisal of $1 damages filed by the defendant on July 10, 1956, for the taking of land of the plaintiffs in the town of Guilford for a highway pursuant to the provisions of the statutes. On November 21, 1956, the defendant filed an amended award, appraising the damages at $44,300. The action was referred to a state referee, and he, by his report, found that the taking price, $44,300, was just, fair and reasonable. After the referee had denied in part the plaintiffs’ motion to correct his report, the plaintiffs took exception to the amended
On July 10, 1956, when the plaintiffs’ land was taken, there was a one-story factory building on it which was occupied by Old Guilford Forge, Inc., a tenant on a month-to-month basis paying a monthly rental of $400. The business of this corporation was the manufacture and sale of colonial hardware. It dealt, also, in reproductions of other colonial items. It used the building for its manufacturing operations and as an office and warehouse and conducted an extensive mail order business from the factory. Old Guilford Forge, Inc., had been incorporated in 1950 by the named plaintiff, who was president of it. His wife, the other plaintiff, was secretary. They were also directors, and with their children and other relatives they owned 83 per cent or more of the outstanding capital stock. A salary paid to the named plaintiff by the corporation was the chief source of his livelihood. The plaintiffs purchased the land in July, 1953, with the plan of developing it in keeping with the early American character of their business and of erecting a retail shop and restaurant in addition to the factory building. In October, 1953, after the factory building had been constructed, they learned of the plan for putting the highway through their property. In October, 1954, they purchased another tract of land in the neighborhood as a new location for their business and with the idea of developing it into an early American center.
In the course of the direct examination of the named plaintiff at the hearing before the referee, he was asked whether moving the business of Old Guil
The plaintiffs concede that the corporation could not recover damages, even though it was required to move its business and to meet the expense of doing so. If the plaintiffs had been the owners of the business conducted upon their premises, it would have been the duty of the trier to consider the expense of moving the machinery to a new location in arriving at the fair market value of the land, not as a separate specific sum of money to be added to the value of the land but as evidence tending to prove its fair market value.
Harvey Textile Co.
v.
Hill,
135 Conn. 686, 689, 67 A.2d 851. “[I]n
The plaintiffs maintain that the conclusion that the taking price of $44,300 was just, fair and reasonable could not legally and properly be drawn. They contend that the defendant was bound by the testimony of his expert, who testified that he had inspected the property and had concluded that the fair market value of the land and building was, as of the
There is no error.
In this opinion the other judges concurred.