Hudson v. MillerHudson v. Miller
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Grimes
This is a petition for a writ of habeas corpus.
*143
The plaintiff was arrested on November 2,1966, and charged with enticing a minor child.
In October 1969, the provisions of
In January 1973, plaintiff was arrested and charged with four counts of simple sexual assault. He was transferred from the local jail to the State hospital on February 14, 1973, for further examination. On May 22, 1973, the Superior Court
(King,
J.) revoked plaintiff’s parole, and, based upon the doctors’ conclusion that plaintiff would not be amenable to treatment, authorized the hospital authorities to transfer him back to the State prison. Plaintiff remained at the prison until July 29,1974, when he was again transferred back to the hospital, where he stayed until February 5,1977, when he escaped. He was arrested on February 6,1977, and charged with two offenses, escape,
*144
The plaintiff filed a pro se petition for a writ of habeas corpus in both the supreme and superior courts.
The plaintiff asserts a history of constitutional deprivations beginning with his original commitment in 1967, under RSA ch. 173, and continuing with his current incarceration at the State prison. We find it unnecessary to address every issue raised, as the requested relief is granted solely on the basis of his current status.
The Sexual Psychopath Act, RSA ch. 173, was enacted in 1949 in response to growing concern “that the frequency of sex crimes within this state necessitates that appropriate measures be adopted to protect society more adequately from aggressive sexual offenders.”
Labelling a proceeding “civil,” however, does not foreclose due process and equal protection safeguards. In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358, 366 (1970); Baxstrom v. Herold, 383 U.S. 107 (1966); Proctor v. Butler, 117 N.H. 927, 932, 380 A.2d 673, 676 (1977); In re Miller, 98 *145 N.H. 107, 108-09, 95 A.2d 116,117 (1953). Nee also State v. Ray 63 N.H. 406 (1885). The need for procedural protection is especially acute when a “civil” commitment proceeding is triggered by an initial involvement in the criminal process. We repeat that “[ijnvolvement in the criminal process is an inadequate reason to justify less procedural and substantive protection against indefinite commitment than that generally available to all others.” Gibbs v. Helgemoe, 116 N.H. 825, 827, 367 A.2d 1041, 1042 (1976), quoting Jackson v. Indiana, 406 U.S. 715, 724 (1972). See generally Note, Constitutional Standards for Release of the Civilly Committed and Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity: A Strict Scrutiny Analysis, 20 Ariz. L. Rev. 233 (1978). In either situation, “civil or criminal, the person is deprived of his liberty, which constitutes a grievous loss.” Gibbs v. Helgemoe, 116 N.H. at 828, 367 A.2d at 1043, citing Morrissey v. Brewer, 408 U.S. 471, 481 (1972); see O’Connor v. Donaldson, 422 U.S. 563 (1975).
By passage of Laws 1973, 556:1, the legislature limited the validity of involuntary civil commitment orders to a period of not more than two years.
Plaintiff’s confinement in the State prison constitutes the very same sort of deprivation of liberty involved in civil and criminal commitments. See Gibbs v. Helgemoe, 116 N.H. at 828, 367 A.2d at 1043. His petition, therefore, deserves the same close look we gave the commitment proceedings involved in State v. Gregoire, 118 N.H. 140, 384 A.2d 132 (1978); Novosel v. Helgemoe, 118 N.H. 115, 384 A.2d 124 (1978); Proctor v. Butler, 117 N.H. 927, 380 A.2d 673 (1977); and Gibbs v. Helgemoe supra.
In the
Gibbs
case, this court could find no rational basis upon which to justify the legislature’s differing release and recommittal procedures for those criminally insane who are committed to the State hospital versus those who are committed to the State prison.
Gibbs v. Helgemoe,
116 N.H. at 827, 367 A.2d at 1043;
see
*146
mentally ill persons in general,” we extended the protection afforded by the express language of
The plaintiff has not been afforded a recommittal hearing within the past two years. We hold that the equal protection clauses of the Federal and New Hampshire Constitutions require that he be released unless he is recommitted pursuant to the same recommittal procedures available to one civilly committed. The State, of course, is free to pursue all available avenues of recommittal. RSA ch. 173, having been repealed by Laws 1969, 443:2, is no longer an available proceeding. The State has thirty days in which to proceed further; otherwise, the plaintiff is to be released. Novosel v. Helgemoe, 118 N.H. 115, 384 A.2d 124 (1978).
The plaintiff also seeks a ruling that he cannot now be tried on either the original criminal charges that led to his 1967 commitment or the 1973 charges that led to his recommittal. The State concedes that it is barred from prosecuting plaintiff on the original charges.
Relief requested is granted unless the State elects to bring recommittal proceedings within thirty days from the date of this opinion.
All concurred.