823 N.Y.S.2d 140 | N.Y. App. Div. | 2006
This action arose out of a dispute over payments allegedly due and owing under a construction management agreement (CMA) entered into between defendant Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) and HRH Construction Interiors, Inc. (Interiors), a subsidiary of HRH Construction Corp., the assets of which were subsequently purchased by plaintiff HRH Construction LLC (HRH LLC). The CMA provided that disputes related to it were to be arbitrated. An arbitration proceeding, putatively between the MTA and Interiors, commenced, but after nine sessions, the MTA learned that HRH LLC, as a result of the asset purchase agreement and management services agreement, had taken over Interiors’ performance of the CMA and, accordingly, was the real party in interest in the arbitration. The MTA moved to join HRH LLC in the arbitration, and HRH LLC commenced this action seeking, inter alia, a permanent injunction preventing the MTA from joining HRH LLC as a party to the arbitration between Interiors and the MTA, or otherwise compelling HRH LLC to arbitrate on the basis of the CMA. HRH LLC moved for a preliminary injunction, and the MTA cross-moved to compel HRH LLC to arbitrate.
A nonsignatory to an agreement containing an arbitration clause that has knowingly received direct benefits under the agreement will be equitably estopped from avoiding the agreement’s obligation to arbitrate (see MAG Portfolio Consultant, GMBH v Merlin Biomed Group LLC, 268 F3d 58, 61 [2d Cir 2001]). Under its asset purchase and management services agreements with Interiors’ parent company, HRH LLC undertook Interiors’ CMA obligations and derived a direct benefit, receiving over $7,000,000 for its performance of the CMA. Accordingly, since HRH LLC knowingly assumed performance of the CMA and derived a direct benefit therefrom, it is estopped from avoiding arbitration under the CMA.
Although plaintiff contends that the MTA learned as early as
We have considered plaintiffs remaining arguments and find them unavailing. Concur—Saxe, J.E, Williams, Gonzalez and Catterson, JJ.