Hoyne v. DanischHoyne v. Danisch
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Carter
delivered the opinion of the court:
The State’s attorney of Cook county filed an information in chancery in the circuit court of that county against appellant, the cleric of the municipal court of Chicago, praying for an order directing said clerk to pay and turn over to the State’s attorney any and all fees, fines, forfeitures and penalties, received by him as clerk of said court since July 6, 1913, and that he be enjoined and restrained from interfering with or preventing appellee from collecting such fees, fines,
The information is based upon the provisions of the act of the legislature approved June n, 1912, (Laws of 1912, —Special Sess.—p. 88,) as amended by an act approved June 27, 1913, (Laws of 1913, p. 360,) fixing the salaries of the State’s attorneys of Illinois and their assistants.- Section 1 of that act as amended provides for the pay of the State’s attorneys of the various counties, section 2 as to the assistant State’s attorneys, and sections 3 and 4 (the part of the act here under consideration) read as follows:
“Sec. 3. The salaries of the State’s attorneys, excepting that part which is to be paid out of the State treasury as now provided for by law, shall be paid out of the county treasury of the county in which the State’s attorney shall reside, in quarterly annual installments on the order of the county board on the treasurer of said county: Provided, that the fees which are now, or may hereafter, be provided by law to be paid by the defendant or defendants, as State’s attorney’s fees, shall be taxed as costs and all fees, fines, forfeitures and penalties shall be collected by the State’s attorney, and shall be paid by him direct into the county treasury. Which said fund shall be held as a special fund to be paid out and distributed as follows: Out of said fund the salaries of the State’s attorney and all assistant- State’s attorneys shall be paid, or so much thereof as said fund will meet, the balance of said salaries, if any, to be paid by said county as herein otherwise provided: And further provided,
“Sec. 4. It is hereby made the duty of all State’s attorneys to report at each term of-the circuit court, the payment and collection of all fees, fines, forfeitures and penalties and to satisfy the court by voucher or otherwise, that all fees, fines, forfeitures and penalties by them collected, have been duly paid over to the county treasurer, as re: quired by section 3 of this act, and the State’s attorney shall have no further interest in conviction fees, fines, forfeitures and penalties or moneys collected by- virtue of such office.”
Section 5 in general terms repeals all laws and parts of laws in conflict with the act, and section 6 specifically repeals an act on the same subject approved June 5, 1911, in force July 1, 1911.
The case has been brought direct to this court on the ground that a constitutional question is involved. Section 10 of article 10 of the constitution of 1870 provides that “the county board, except as provided in section 9 of this article, shall fix the compensation of all county officers,” etc. It is argued that this court has held that the State’s attorney is a county officer, (Cook County v. Healy, 222 Ill. 310; Peoples Cook County Comrs. 260 id. 345;) and that as the State’s attorneys are not within the exceptions in section 9 of said article 10, the county board, under
The further argument is made that this act is in contravention of that part of section 12 of article 10 of the constitution which provides that the General Assembly shall by general law, uniform in its operation, provide for and regulate the fees of officers and their successors, so as tó reduce the same to a reasonable compensation for services actually rendered. The argument of counsel, as we understand it, on this point is, that under the provisions of this statute all the fees earned by the State’s attorney in any given county may not be required to pay for the salary of the State’s attorney or other legal expenses of the office and some
The principal question argued here is the proper construction to be given to this statute as to the authority and duty of the State’s attorney touching the collection of fees, fines, forfeitures and penalties, counsel for appellee arguing that the State’s attorney must receive and collect all fees,’ fines, forfeitures and penalties that the law requires paid in all cases, prosecutions and actions arising in the county in which the State is a party; that no clerk of a court or justice of the peace or other public official is now authorized, under this act, to accept any of such fines, fees, forfeitures or penalties, as they were previous to its passage; that this act repeals, directly or by implication, all provisions of other statutes not in harmony with said act, construed as here contended for. It appears that there is a controversy on this question not only between the State’s attorney and appellant, but between the State’s áttorney and many other public officials who
The first general statute on this subject, in force July 1, 1872, provided that each State’s attorney should be paid by the State’ the sum of $400. each year, quarterly, out of any money in the treasury not otherwise appropriated and be allowed fees in certain enumerated cases, with ten per cent commissions on all moneys, except revenue, collected by him, and also required the State’s attorney to make a report at every term of the circuit court as to his fines and collections. The statute on fees, fines and forfeitures was amended by an act which went into force July 1, 1883. The only material change bearing on the question here under consideration was that the State’s attorneys should have “a lien for their fees on judgments for fines or forfeitures procured by them for their fees and earnings until they are fully paid,” etc. This statute was amended by acts going into force July 1, 1889, July 1, 1907, and July 1, 1909, but none of these amendments affected the questions here under consideration. Several laws were passed previous to this last date which affected only Cook county, the first one July 1, 1871, which fixed the salary of the State’s attorney of Cook county at $7000, the balance over and above the amount paid by the State to be paid by Cook county. An act was passed going into force July 1, 1901, which fixed the salary of the State’s attorney of Cook county at $70,-000. This provision of the act having been declared unconstitutional in Cook County v. Healy, supra, to obviate the defects in the act last referred to, an act was passed going into force July x, 1907, again fixing the fees of the State’s attorney of Cook county at $10,000. The general statutes governing fees, fines
Before the enactment of said amendment of July 1, 1913, the State’s attorneys, as well as other officials collecting fines, forfeitures and penalties, were required to pay them over to the county superintendent of schools. This provision was in the School law previous to the constitution of 1870. By the same act the clerks of courts of record and justices of the peace collecting such fines and forfeitures were required to make an annual report to the county superintendent of schools. This law was enacted February 1, 1865, and remained in force until July 1, 1872, when an act revising the School law of the State was passed. The provisions as to the disposition of fines, penalties and forfeitures and
A study of these various acts as. they affect the compensation of the State’s attorney and the collection and disposition of fines, penalties and forfeitures demonstrates that the chief purpose of the State’s Attorney Salary act, as amended July 1, 1913, was to provide a method of paying the State’s attorneys regular salaries quarterly, using therefor, so far as required, all the proceeds of fines, penalties and forfeitures collected by various officials, the net proceeds of which theretofore had been paid over to the county superintendents of schools for general school purposes, and further providing that if after the payment of such salaries there was any balance left, such balance should be paid to the county superintendents, to be used for school purposes. Counsel for both parties will doubtless agree as to the statement just made but sharply disagree as to whether the net proceeds from any fines, penalties
Counsel for appellee, under their cross-errors, question the correctness of the ruling of the trial court as to the provisions of some fifteen different statutes, viz.:
(1) . As to the disposition of the fines collected under an act in force July 1, 1885, to prevent fraud in the manufacture and sale of commercial fertilizers. (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 44.) Section 6 of this act provides that a suit shall be brought for the recovery of fines or damages, under the provisions of the act, in the county in which the fertilizer was offered for sale or where manufactured, “and all fines so recovered shall be paid into the treasury of the State board of agriculture by the court collecting the same.”
(2) The disposition of the fines under an act concerning Canada thistles, in force March 13, 1872, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 135,) paragraph 8ji of which provides that the fines thereunder are “to be sued for in any court of competent jurisdiction in the name of the town on complaint of any land owner of the town; said fine when collected to be paid to the supervisor or county commissioner and become a part of the town or precinct fund.”
(3) The disposition of fines and penalties under an act relating to the Illinois and Michigan canal, in force July 1, 1874, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 138,) section 27 of the act providing that “all fines and penalties herein provided for may be recovered before any justice of the peace of the
(4) The disposition of fines under an act to protect cemeteries and provide for their regulation, in force July 1, 1885, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 156,) section 1 of which provides that the fines recovered under this provision “shall be paid over by the court or. officer receiving the same to the cemetery association and be applied, as far as possible, in repairing the injury, if any, caused by such offense.”
(5) The disposition of fines for the violation of the Pish and Game act, approved June 23, 1913, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 1310,) the 60th section of which provides that “all fines imposed for a violation of any of the provisions of this act shall, when collected, be paid to the State treasurer, by the justice of the peace, clerk of court, or other officer by whom such fine is collected.”
(6) The disposition of the penalties collected under an act to regulate the surrender and placing of children, in force July 1, 1905, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 240,) section 4 of which provides that any penalties under the act may be recovered “in action of debt before a justice of the peace or any competent court, for the benefit of the school fund of the district in which recovery is had.”
(7) The disposition of fines paid in money in prosecutions for cruelty to animals or children, under an act with reference thereto in force July 1, 1885, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 885,) section 1 of the act providing that all fines paid in money through the agency of the humane society shall, when collected, be paid into the treasury of such society, to be applied towards its support.
(8) The disposition of the penalties prescribed in the Pharmacy act, in force July 1, 1901, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 1606,) section 15 of which provides that “all suits for the recovery of the several penalties prescribed in this act shall
(9) The disposition of fines and penalties collected under an act to regulate dental surgery, in force July 1, 1909, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 1612,) section 16 of the act providing, “all fines imposed and collected under this act shall be paid to the Illinois State Board of Dental Examiners for its use.”
(10) The disposition of penalties under an act in force July 1, 1877, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 1948,) to compel railroad companies to build and maintain depots, section 2 of the act providing that after ninety days’ failure to comply with the provisions of said section, after notice, the railroad company shall pay to the town or village for each day’s neglect the sum of $50, “to be recovered in an action of debt before any justice of the peace, in the name of the People of the State of Illinois, in any town or village aggrieved. Said penalty to be paid to the said town or village for the school fund.”
■ (11) The disposition of fines provided for under an act in relation to fencing and operating railroads, .in force July-i, 1874, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 1951,) section 11 of said act providing that fines under the said act shall be enforced “in the name of the People of the State of Illinois, before any court of competent jurisdiction in the county. Such fine, when collected, to be paid into the treasury of the authorities enforcing the fine.”
(12) The disposition of the moneys arising from the enforcement of certain provisions of an act to establish railroad and warehouse commissioners, in force July 1, 1871, (Hurd’s Stat. 1911, p. 1847,) section 18 of which provides that
(13) The disposition of fines and penalties recovered under the provisions of an act to revise the law in relation to roads and bridges, in force July 1, 1913, (Hurd’s Stab 1913, p. 2150,) section 156 of said act providing that “all fines and penalties recovered under the provisions of this act for offenses committed upon or in relation to State aid roads, shall, unless otherwise provided, be paid over to the County treasurer, and by him transmitted to the State treasurer to become a part of the State road and bridge fund. All fines and penalties recovered under the provisions of this act for offenses committed upon or in relation to all other roads shall, unless otherwise provided, be paid over to the treasurer of the road and bridge fund of the town or district where the offense is committed to be expended upon the roads and bridges in said district or town,” etc.
(14) The disposition of fines collected as to motor vehicles under the Motor Vehicle law, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 2155,) section 18 of which provides that all fines imposed for the violation of any provision of the act shall be paid “to the treasurer of the highway commissioners of the township or road district in which the offense is committed by the justice of the peace, clerk of the court, or other officer to whom the’ amount of such fines shall be by law required to be paid by the constable, bailiff, sheriff, or other officer, * * * and all money so received by the treasurer of the highway commissioners shall be used in repairing and improving the roads within such township or road district,” with the further provision that if the violation occurs within the limits of a
(15) The disposition of fines and penalties under the State Pure «Food law, in force July 1, 1907, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 2321,) section 2yi of which provides that “all fines, penalties, and all proceeds collected from goods confiscated and sold under the provisions of this act and other laws relating to dairy and food products, and all license fees collected hereunder, shall be paid into the State treasury.!’
The disposition of the fines and penalties under said fifteen specified acts is all that is questioned by the cross-errors by counsel for the appellee. There are, however, fines and penalties under other acts, which, if the reasoning of counsel for the appellee is to be followed, might also reasonably be construed in the same manner. We will refer to a few of them.
Under section 9 of the act to revise-the law in relation to the State library, in force July 1, 1874, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 2343,) it is provided that all fines and forfeitures accruing by virtue of the act shall be recoverable in the name of the People of the State of Illinois, to the use of the State library. Section 14 of the act requiring reports on births and deaths, in force July 1, 1903, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 2291,) provides that all fines collected under the provisions of the act shall be paid into the county treasury of the county, the State’s attorney prosecuting. It is not stated that the State’s attorney shall collect these funds or that any of the net proceeds left after paying the legal expenses of the State’s attorney’s office shall be paid over to the school fund. Under the act relating to employment offices and agencies, in force May xi, 1903, (Hurd’s Stat. 1913, p. 1185,) as amended by an act in force July 1, 1909, it is provided in section 12 that all moneys received from fees and fines under the act shall be held by the commissioners of labor
If the construction of the State’s Attorney Salary act be as contended for by counsel for appellee, then it might well be argued that the provisions of every one of the acts just referred to as to the disposition of fines and penalties, as well as many other statutes inflicting fines and penalties not referred to in this opinion, would be repealed and all such fines and penalties be paid to the State’s attorney, to be applied towards thp payment of the salaries and legal
Counsel for appellee argue that the amendatory act of 1913 expressly repeals “all laws or parts of laws in conflict” therewith, and that the provisions • of all these excluded laws as to the disposition of fines are in conflict with the Salary act. While the insertion of a general provision in a statute declaring a repeal of all inconsistent acts or parts of acts (without naming any particular act) implies that the new statute is to some extent repugnant to certain laws theretofore enacted, the insertion of such a general repealing clause is generally held to add nothing to the repealing effect of the act. Logically, such a general repealing section adds nothing to the language or meaning of the act and takes nothing from it. All prior conflicting laws and parts of laws are impliedly repealed by conflicting provisions of the law enacted. (1 Lewis’ Sutherland on Stat. Const.—2d ed.—sec. 256, and cases there cited.) Repeals by implication are not favored. Under the authorities both statutes remain in force unless they are so repugnant that they cannot operate together. (People v. Harrison, 185 Ill. 307; People v. Raymond, 186 id. 407; Galpin v. City of Chicago, 249 id. 554.) The intention of the law-makers is the law. This intention is to be gathered from the necessity or reason of the enactment and the meaning of the words, enlarged or restricted according to their real intent. (Cruse v. Aden, 127 Ill. 231.) In determining the meaning of a statute the court will always have regard to existing circumstances, contemporaneous conditions, the objects sought to be attained by the statute and the necessity or want of necessity for its adoption. (People v. Kipley, 171 Ill. 44.) In seeking for such- an intention we are to consider the language used by the legislature, the evil to be remedied and the object to be attained. (Hogan v. Akin, 181 Ill. 448.) In construing a statute the courts are not confined to the literal meaning of the words. A thing within
All seeming conflict between the acts in question can be harmonized or done away with by giving a reasonable construction to the word “all.” In the State’s Attorney Salary act the purpose sought was to have all State’s attorneys and their assistants placed upon regular salaries, to be paid out of such fines, penalties and forfeitures of the kind the net proceeds of which .theretofore had been paid over ■to the county superintendents for school purposes. So construed, the only change in the existing laws as to the collection and disposition of fines, penalties and forfeitures is, that hereafter all fines, penalties and forfeitures the net proceeds of which heretofore went
The further question remains for consideration as to whether the decree is correct in enjoining and restraining appellant from collecting any such fines, forfeitures and penalties in suits arising in the municipal court of Chicago in which the State of Illinois is a party. In our judgment the legislature did not intend to .prevent the clerks of courts of record or justices of the peace or other officials who have heretofore lawfully collected fines, penalties and forfeitures, from thereafter collecting such fines, penalties and forfeitures. -The legislature intended that instead of the clerks
The decree of the circuit court will therefore be reversed and the cause remanded, with directions to enter a decree in accordance with the views herein expressed.
Reversed and remanded, with directions.