Horton v. Fleming Co.Horton v. Fleming Co.
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Rees
Wayne L. Horton was fatally injured on July 3, 1974, as the result of an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment by Fleming Company. A workmen’s compensation claim was filed on behalf of his dependent surviving spouse and minor children. The award to the dependents entered by the examiner on October 8, 1976, was approved on review and appeal by the director and district court.
The examiner found
“(j) When any benefits are being paid under the federal social security act because of the death of an employee whose dependents are entitled to compensation under this section, the amount of compensation due under this section shall be reduced by an amount equal to one-half (Vi) of the amount of such social security payments during the time such social security payments are being made to the workman’s dependents.”
In Kansas it is well established that a workmen’s compensation claim is contractual in nature and that the cause of action accrues on the date of injury or death. The substantive rights of the parties are determined by the law in effect on the date of injury or death. An amendment to the workmen’s compensation act or, as in this case, a repeal of a part of the act, which is procedural or remedial in nature, and which does not prejudicially affect the substantive rights of the parties, applies to pending cases. Generally, an amendment will operate prospectively unless its language clearly indicates retroactive application and retroactive application will not impair vested rights. Baker v. List and Clark Construction Co., 222 Kan. at 133, 134; Lyon v. Wilson, 201 Kan. 768, 774, 443 P.2d 314 (1968); Eakes v. Hoffman-LaRoche, Inc., 220 Kan. 565, 569, 552 P.2d 998 (1976); See also In re Estate of Laue, 225 Kan. 177, Syl. ¶ 4, 589 P.2d 558 (1979).
In other jurisdictions, it has been held that the amount of compensation payable to a workmen’s compensation claimant is a matter of substance rather than procedure. Cooper v. Wicomico County, 278 Md. 596, 598-599, 366 A.2d 55 (1976); Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Industrial Acc. Com’n., 174 P.2d 41, 44-49 (Cal. App. 1946), aff’d 30 Cal. 2d 388, 182 P.2d 159 (1947); Riggs v. Lehigh Portland Cement Co., 76 Ind. App. 308, 131 N.E. 231 (1921). We agree. The reasoning in Riggs is persuasive. In that case, application of an Indiana workmen’s compensation act amendment would have changed the amount of an award upon remarriage of the claimant. The court stated:
“Can the Legislature increase this award by raising the rate or by extending the compensation period? Can the award be disturbed in any manner by subsequent legislation? We are of the opinion that the rights of all concerned were fixed by the act under which the award was made, and may not be modified by subsequent legislation. If the legislature may increase awards, it may also decrease awards. To permit subsequent legislation to increase or diminish the compensation specified in awards would be to strike down vested rights. Then no one would be secure. The resulting uncertainty, distrust and confusion would destroy the compensation plan itself.” 76 Ind. App. at 311.
*123
Because of the repeal of
“In view of what has been said we think the statute was remedial in character and deprived appellant of no vested right. A statute which merely changes a remedy is not unconstitutional, although it is applied retroactively.” 159 Kan. at 218-219.
The court also found language in the amendment indicating an intent for retroactive application. 159 Kan. at 217-218.
We conclude that the 1977 repeal of
Examination of
Affirmed.