Holmes v. Calhoun CountyHolmes v. Calhoun County
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Kinne
I. Plaintiff, a landowner in Calhoun county, Iowa, brings this action to enjoin the county, its auditor, treasurer and board of supervisors, from constructing a tile drain upon and along the highway adjacent to his premises, He avers that the *361board of supervisors had entered into a contract with a party to construct such a drain along the south line of his land; that the same is so planned as to drain, not only the highway, but also to carry off the water which accumulates on the land lying south of the highway; that the construction of the drain, as planned, will accumulate immediately opposite plaintiff’s land, on said highway, a much larger amount of water than would naturally accumulate at that place, and would empty all of said water, suddenly, and in large and unusual quantities, upon his land; that said drain will change the natural flow of the water, and discharge the water upon his land, to his damage. He further avers that there is no lawful authority to improve the highway, as there is no fund which can legally be used to pay therefor. He asks that an injunction issue, restraining the entering into the contract for tbe construction of said drain, the issuing of a warrant to pay therefor, and the payment of any such warrant, and for other equitable relief. The answer avers • that the construction of the drain was necessary to render the highway passable; that it would empty the water into the natural outlet; that its construction would not damage plaintiff; that the county road fund was not in debt; that the tile for said drain had been paid for, and the work of putting in the drain provided for; that plaintiff has an adequate remedy at law. The cause was tried to the court, and a decree entered, enjoining the defendant county, and its board of supervisors and,their successors, from constructing or maintaining said drain, or any similar drain, “whereby the surplus water will be cast, artificially, on the premises of plaintiff, and said defendants are enjoined and prohibited from permitting the water from said drain from flowing upon said land of plaintiff.” The auditor was also *362enj oinecl from issuing any warrants on the bridge fund of said county, in payment for said drain; and the treasurer, from paying any such warrants. Defendants appeal.
*363