Case Case4:12-cv-05350-SBA 4:12-cv-05350-SBA Document Document16 18 Filed12/21/12 Filed 01/02/13 Page1 Page 1ofof22 XXXXXXXXX  Case Case4:12-cv-05350-SBA 4:12-cv-05350-SBA Document Document16 18 Filed12/21/12 Filed 01/02/13 Page2 Page 2ofof22 XXXXXXXXXX X 1/2/13