Hinman v. HinmanHinman v. Hinman
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Sabers
Sheila Hinman (Sheila) appeals a divorce decree granting physical custody of the minor children to Robert Hinman (Robert). The case is controlled by statutory construction of
PROCEDURAL FACTS
Sheila claims that it was improper for Circuit Judge Kean to enter findings of fact and conclusions of law because he did not hear the evidence at trial and was unfamiliar with the case. Judge Heuer-mann tried the case and decided it from the bench. However, he became ill within two weeks after the trial and was hospitalized prior to signing findings of fact and conclusions of law. Sheila filed a motion for reconsideration of Judge Heuermann’s decision. Before the motion was heard, Sheila submitted findings of fact and conclusions of law to Judge Heuermann, who was still hospitalized. After Robert submitted proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law, Sheila scheduled a hearing on the motion for reconsideration before Judge Amundson. Robert objected to this hearing and requested Judge Kean, presiding judge of the circuit, to enter findings of fact and conclusions of law. After reviewing the transcript and Judge Heuermann’s decision and comments, Judge Kean signed Robert’s proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law and entered a judgment. Sheila argues that Judge Kean’s actions were contrary to
DECISION
Sheila argues that under
If by reason of death, sickness, or other disability ... a judge before whom an action has been tried is unable to perform the duties to be by him performed after a verdict is returned or findings of fact and conclusions of law are filed, *661 then any other judge regularly sitting in or assigned to the court in which the action was tried may perform those duties[.] (emphasis added).
The key language in
Finally, we note that Judge Heuermann returned to his duties in time to sign an order waiving bond in Sheila’s appeal. There appears to have been no great haste or need for Judge Kean’s signature in this case. Judge Heuermann could have signed findings of fact and conclusions of law while he was in the hospital or when he returned to his duties. Absent his signature or an appropriate stipulation by the parties, the case must be reversed and remanded.
All the Justices concur.