Hilton v. RoylanceHilton v. Roylance
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Bartch
having stated the facts as above, delivered the opinion of the court.
The principal question to be determined is, were John R. Park and Annie E. Armitage lawfully married on December 5, 1872 ? The appellant insists that- the ceremony was performed according to the rites of the Mormon Church, by a person authorized to perform it, that it was a legal marriage, and valid at common law; and that the court erred in finding that the parties never intermarried and were never husband and wife. The respondent contends that there never was a marriage in this case, because, as is insisted, there never was any consent to a marriage contract, and that the burden was upon the plaintiff to prove a marriage contract, which it is claimed she failed to do. It is insisted by the respondent that the “sealing ceremony” which was performed and is relied upon as constituting a marriage ceremony simply made the parties thereto husband and wife for eternity (that is, after death, but not for time or this world, nor for time and *137eternity), and that Dr. Park consented to be sealed to the plaintiff for eternity only. So far as appears from the record the sealing ceremony performed in this instance was, in substance, such as it was the custom to perform where members of the Mormon Church entered into matrimony. It is a ceremony peculiar to that church and its people, who constitute a large majority of the inhabitants of this commonwealth, and the importance of the main question herein presented, as affecting the marriage status and property rights in this State, must not be overlooked; for if, under the facts and circumstances disclosed in this record, there was no marriage, then it would seem impossible to conjecture how many of such sealing ceremonies, although performed by ordinance of the church, were, after all, mere nullities, creating no valid marital relations.
Marriage, strictly speaking, is not a mere civil contract, but a status created by contract. 1 Bish. Mar. & Div., sec. 34. It is true, it is founded in consent of the parties, but the consent is the contract because of which the status
Looking now, in the light of these principles, at the facts and circumstances disclosed by the evidence herein, what did the parties intend at the time the sealing ceremony was performed ? Did they then mutually assent to and contract a marriage under the law, or was it to be simply a marriage for eternity, which the law does not recognize? The evidence clearly shows, and it is admitted, that a sealing ceremony was performed, and that both parties mutually consented to it. The proof likewise shows that the sealing ceremony, whether it was for time and eternity, or merely for eternity, as claimed by the respondent, was performed under an ordinance of the Mormon Church, by an official thereof who was fully authorized to officiate on such occasions. Both parties were members of that church, and believed! in its doctrines. Prom the testimony of the plaintiff, it appears that, both before and for some time after the performance of the ceremony, the relations of the parties were quite intimate; that on their voyage and at New- York, Dr. Park was very attentive to her; that in Salt Lake City, and while on her bed of sickness, he visited her quite frequently; that she was assured by the witness Mrs. Young, at whose house she lay sick, that the doctor wished to make her his wife, and was *141advised to be sealed to bim, being told that she might die, and that it would be better for ber to be sealed to some good man, as it would make ber position in the‘next world more exalted; that at the ceremony by the bedside they joined their right bands; that the officiating clergyman then asked the doctor whether he was willing to take her (the plaintiff) to be Ms “lawful wedded wife,” and received an affirmative reply; that to a similar inquiry the plaintiff gave an affirmative answer; and that, after some further ceremony by the clergyman, they were pronounced husband and wife. It is true, several witnesses testified that at the time of the performance of the ceremony the plaintiff appeared to them as if she were unconscious, but the clearness with which she has described the details of the occurrence, many of them being fully corroborated by other witnesses and the surrounding circumstances shown by the testimony, impel the conclusion that the plaintiff was not only conscious, although very sick, but fully understood what was going on. It will be noticed, upon reference to the testimony, that the witness Mrs. H. C. Wells, who was present at the sealing ceremony, said: “I only remember that there was a ceremony, and that they were married.” Upon the ceremony having been performed, the person officiating issued a certificate stating that the “parties were sealed,” which certificate was recorded in the office of the church historian.
Without further reference to the evidence in detail, there can be no doubt that both parties intended to be “sealed,” whatever that may include, and that they both mutually consented to the sealing ceremony. Whether sealing, as an ordinance of the church of which both the parties were members, embraces the marriage status, under the laws of matrimony, or whether it instituted simply a marriage, under the doctrines peculiar to that church, for eternity, remains to be seen. The respondent insists that the parties did not agree or consent to be husband and wife during their joint lives, but only to *142be husband and wife after both were dead; and, if this be true, then the occurrence was simply something of which the law takes no cognizance, and by which neither one was legally bound. The parties, however, must be held to have consented to and intended whatever their language and acts fairly and legitimately indicate. The most important subject of inquiry on this branch of the case, therefore, is what was meant by the term “sealed,” or “sealing ceremony.” This point was made an issue in the pleadings, for the plaintiff alleged marriage, and the defendant denied marriage, but admitted that the parties were sealed in accordance with a tenet of the Mormon Church. The question then immediately arose as to whether or not such a sealing constituted a valid marriage. At the trial the testimony introduced to show the meaning of the term “sealed,” or “sealing ceremony,” was very meager and wholly unsatisfactory. It is true, several witnesses attempted to state what was meant by the word “sealing,” and the respondent contends that their evidence preponderates to the effect that sealing did not mean marriage; but when it is considered that none of them were shown or appear to be qualified to speak upon the subject, and that not a single officer of the church who was qualified was put upon the stand, although the issue was raised affirmatively by the defense, the testimony in question can be regarded as of little, if of any, importance in the determination of what is the meaning of those terms. Counsel for the respondent refer to Webster’s definition of the word “seal,” as used in common, parlance, but what light can Webster’s definition throw upon this subject ? Its ordinary use is easily comprehended, but here it has a particular meaning assigned to it by the Mormon Church, by the authority of which church the ceremony was performed, and the meaning of the term which was thus given to it by the church must determine the sense in which it was and is used in the performance of the sealing ordinance. The church, as an organized ecclesiastical body, had the right to declare *143and adapt tenets, rules, and ordinances, not inconsistent with or repugnant to tbe laws of tbe land, for its own governance and‘tbe guidance and conduct of its members; and tbe same’ are binding upon the members, and will he respected by tbe courts in passing upon questions relating to ecclesiastical affairs. When, therefore, tbe parties, in tbe present instance, wbo were both members of that cbnrcb, were sealed according to tbe tenet, thereof, they became bound by tbe relations of husband and wife, under tbe law of matrimony, if, in accordance with tbe particular significance given to tbe word’ “sealed,” tbe sealing included those relations. And if by tbe sealing ceremony, and assent thereto, a marriage was solemnized for time as well as for eternity, then tbe marriage is good, and must be respected by tbe civil courts, notwithstanding that part of tbe contract and ceremony which related to eternity, for that may be regarded as mere surplusage. In Baxter v. McDonnell, 155 N. Y. 83, 49 N. E. 667, 40 L. R. A. 670, which was an action by a priest against a bishop of tbe Holy Roman Catholic Church to recover an alleged sum due him as salary, it was said: “When an individual joins an incorporated club or legally organized body, with power to make laws and rules for its own government and for tbe regulation of tbe conduct of its members, tbe member becomes bound by those laws and rules; and a decision by tbe body or a duly constituted committee, proceeding according to judicial forms, touching bis rights or relations as a member, is binding upon the courts. . . . He can always insist, of course, that bis civil or property rights as an individual or citizen shall be determined according to tbe law of tbe land; but bis relations, rights, and obligations arising from bis position as a member of some religious body may be’ determined according to tbe laws and procedure enacted by that body for such purpose.”
Tbe proof as to tbe meaning of tbe term “sealed,” or “sealing ordinance,” being unsatisfactory, tbe only other *144source of information would seem to- be works of history and cbnrcb records and journals; but counsel, for tbe respondent
Having thus determined that we can take judicial notice of the works of history and theology offered in evidence and rejected, it now behooves us to ascertain what the particular meaning of the word “sealed” is, according to historical and the theological authority of the Mormon Church, and
“Verily, thus saith the Lord unto you, my servant Joseph, that inasmuch as you have inquired of my hand, to know and understand wherein I, the Lord, justified my servants Abraham, Isaac and Jacob; as also Moses, David and Solomon, my servants, as touching the principle and doctrine of their having many wives and concubines.”
In this paragraph, as will’ be noticed, the doctrine of a plurality of wives is mentioned, and the word “wives” is used as a general term, and includes the first wife as well as plural wives.
Paragraph 4 states:
“Eor behold! I reveal unto you a new and everlasting covenant; and if you abide not that covenant, then are ye damned; for no one can reject this covenant, and be permitted to enter into my glory.”
Here notice of a new and everlasting covenant is given, and a penalty fixed for disobedience thereof. The penalty is that those who do not abide by the covenant will be “damned.” The new covenant referred to is that of marriage, or “celestial marriage,” as it has been characterized.
Paragraph 7 reads:
“And verily I say unto you, that the conditions of this law are these: All covenants, contracts, bonds, obligations, oaths, vows, performances, connections, associatons, or ex*147pectations, that are not made, and entered into, and sealed by the Holy Spirit of promise, of bim wbo is anointed, both as well for time and for all eternity, and that, too, most holy by revelation and commandment, through the medium of mine anointed, whom I have appointed on the earth to hold this power (and I have appointed’ unto my servant Joseph to hold this power in the last days, and there is never but one on the earth at a time, on whom this power and the keys of the priesthood are conferred) are of no efficacy, virtue or force, in and after the resurrection from the dead; for all contracts that are hot made unto this end, have an end when men are dead.”
Here is revealed how the new covenant shall be made and performed, by or through whom it must be performed or “sealed,” and its duration. In this paragraph also appears the reason for sealing in marriage, which is that the family union, the relations of husband and’ wife, may continue in effect in the eternal world.
In paragraph 18 it is said:
“And again, verily I say unto you, if a man marry a wife, and make a covenant with her for time and for all eternity, if that covenant is not by me, or by my word, which is my law, and is not sealed by the Holy Spirit of promise, through him whom I have anointed and appointed unto this power — then it is not valid, neither of force when they are out of the world, because they are not joined by me, saith the Lord, neither by my word.”
This states, probably more clearly, what is implied in paragraph 7, that a marriage by contract or covenant for time and eternity, not sealed by the Holy Spirit of promise, through the “anointed,” is not valid, nor of force when the parties are out of the world.
In paragraph 19 occurs this language:
“And again, verily I say unto you, if a man marry a wife by word, which is my law, and by the new and everlast*148ing covenant, and it is sealed unto them by the Holy Spirit of promise, by him who is anointed, unto whom I have appointed this power, and the keys of this priesthood; and it shall be said unto them, ye shall come forth in the first resurrection; and if it be after the first resurrection, in the next resurrection; and shall inherit thrones, kingdoms, principalities, and powers, dominions, all heights and depths —then shall it be written in the Lamb’s Book of Life, that he shall commit no murder whereby to shed innocent blood.”
Here it affirmatively appears that if a marriage is by the “new and everlasting covenant,” and is sealed as provided in the revealed law, it will be of force forever, and the promise is that the parties “shall come forth in the first resurrection,” and “shall inherit thrones, kingdoms, principalities,” etc., and shall be exalted and glorified in eternity. And in paragraph 61 the language is:
“And again, as pertaining to the law of the priesthood: If any man espouse a virgin, and desire to espouse another, and the first give her consent; and if he espouses the second, and they are virgins, and have vowed to no other man, then is he justified; he can not commit adultery, for they are given unto him‘; for he can not commit adultery with that that be>-longeth unto him and to no one else.”
As will be observed, this paragraph refers to plural marriages, and shows that they are justified by and are of force under the revelation, and that cohabitation, after sealing or marriage, is not considered adulterous.
The revelation, comprising 66 paragraphs, is found in section 132, Book of Doctrines and Covenants of the Mormon Church, and is entitled: , “Revelation on the Eternity of the Marriage Covenant, Including Plurality of Wives. Given
*150Now, the evidence in the case at bar discloses the fact that both parties to the sealing ceremony were members of the Mormon Ohurch, and believed in its doctrines and
In the light of these authorities, can there be any doubt that in Mormon Church parlance “sealed” means the same thing as the word “married,” or that a “sealing ceremony” is with the Latter-Day Saints a “marriage ceremony?” Is it not apparent that by them these terms are used interchangeably and are synonymous ? With them, whether the solemnization of the covenant of marriage be called a “sealing ceremony” or a “marriage ceremony,” it means the
It would seem useless to pursue this subject further. Its intricacies and importance, touching the validity of marriages in this State, and the resultant property rights, impelled us to bestow upon its consideration careful thought and research. As a result of our investigations, the eonclu*159sion that the sealing ceremony performed in tbis case established tbe marriage status and created tbe relations of husband and wife is irresistible.
The marriage, then, having been lawfully created, was it in force at the time when the respondent purchased the property in dispute ? This question must be answered in the affirmative, unless the marriage status had previously been
We are of the opinion that the finding and holding of the court that the plaintiff and Dr. John E. Park were never married, and that she is entitled to no part of the estate of the deceased, are so manifestly erroneous that they can not be upheld ; and the case must therefore, be- reversed, with costs, and the cause remanded, with directions to the court below to set *160aside its findings and decree, and enter new findings and decree in accordance herewith. It is so ordered.
MINER, O. J., and BASKIN, J., concur.