Higginbotham v. BarnhartHigginbotham v. Barnhart
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Jolly
Today we decide a question of only narrow interest but of significance to some Social Security appeals: Whether, in reviewing the denial of supplemental security income (“SSI”) benefits, the courts should consider evidence that the claimant did not present to the Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”), but submitted for the first time to the Appeals Council, which accepted and considered the evidence but denied review of the ALJ decision. The Commissioner of Social Security argues that it should not be considered because it is not part of the Commissioner’s “final decision.”
Specifically, Charles D. Higginbotham, the claimant and appellant, argues, however, that the district court, in affirming the Commissioner’s denial of benefits, erred in failing to consider a statement made by his treating physician, which he presented for the first time before the Appeals Council. To answer this question, we must determine what constitutes the Social Security Commissioner’s “final decision.” This is a close and confusing question to resolve because neither the statute nor the regulations are clear. After our study of the relevant statutory provisions and regulations, however, we conclude that the Commissioner’s “final decision” includes the Appeals Council’s denial of Higginbotham’s request for review. We therefore remand to the district court for consideration of the entire record on appeal, including the new evidence submitted by Higginbotham for the first time to the Appeals Council.
I
Higginbotham applied for SSI benefits in 1999, claiming that he had most recently worked in 1994 and that mixed bipolar disorder rendered him totally disabled. In 2000, the Social Security Administration denied Higginbotham’s application. Higginbotham then requested, and was granted, a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”). The ALJ denied Higginbotham’s claim for benefits because Higginbotham could not sustain a claim of total disability. Specifically, the ALJ held that Higginbotham had no “exertional limitations,” but that he did have “non-exer-tional limitations” that restricted him to jobs requiring only short, simple instructions and limited interaction with other people.
Higginbotham timely filed a request for review by the Appeals Council. While his request was pending, Higginbotham, in accordance with applicable regulations, submitted a medical source statement completed by Chandrakant Patel, M.D. (“Dr. Patel”), his treating physician. That statement included Dr. Patel’s evaluation of Higginbotham’s “mental abilities critical for performing unskilled work.” Dr. Patel concluded that Higginbotham suffered from a complete loss of ability to perform regular employment activity. In a letter dated August 30, 2001, the Appeals Council denied Higginbotham’s request for review, noting that although it had considered Dr. Patel’s statement, the additional evidence did not provide a basis for reversing the AL J’s decision.
Next, Higginbotham filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, seeking review of the Commissioner’s denial of SSI benefits. Then, in October 2003, the magistrate judge recommended that the Commissioner’s decision be reversed. Judge McBryde, however, rejected the magis
II
Our review of the Commissioner’s denial of SSI benefits is limited to considering whether the decision is supported by substantial evidence in the record and whether the proper legal standards were applied. 1 See Villa v. Sullivan, 895 F.2d 1019, 1022 (5th Cir.1990). A reviewing court may not, however, examine only the evidence favorable to the Commissioner; it must also examine contrary evidence. See Randall v. Sullivan, 956 F.2d 105, 109 (5th Cir.1992).
The precise issue raised by this appeal is whether the district court should have reviewed and considered the evidence that Higginbotham submitted to the Appeals Council but failed to present to the ALJ. The Social Security Act provides that courts may review the “final decision” of the Commissioner.
Thus, in interpreting the Social Security Act and the applicable regulations, if we determine that the final decision encompasses the Appeals Council’s denial of review, then we must conclude that the district court erred in failing to consider the new evidence. If we determine that a final decision does not include the denial of the request for review, then we must hold that the district court did not err in declining to consider and address Dr. Patel’s statement.
Ill
The question whether the denial of review by the Appeals Council constitutes part of the Commissioner’s “final decision,” and consequently whether the new evidence should be considered by the district court on appeal, has split the circuits. Until today we had not decided this question.
See Masterson v. Barnhart,
309 F.3d 267, 274 n. 3 (5th Cir.2002). The Commissioner advocates the position adopted by the Third, Sixth, Seventh, and Eleventh Circuits, which have decided that when the Appeals Council denies a claimant’s request for review, the “final decision” to be reviewed by a district court on appeal is only the actual decision of the ALJ.
2
They
On the other hand, Higginbotham urges us to adopt the position taken by the Second, Fourth, Eighth, Ninth, and Tenth Circuits, all of which have held that evidence submitted for the first time before the Appeals Council should be considered by the district court because the Appeals Council’s denial of the request for review is part of the “final decision.” 3
These courts based their decisions on the following reasons. First,
IV
When we weigh the competing arguments interpreting the applicable regulations, we are persuaded that the Commissioner’s final decision includes the Appeals Council’s denial of a request for review.
It is true that the courts generally agree that when the Appeals Council denies a request for review, the ALJ’s decision becomes the Commissioner’s final decision.
See Sims,
530 U.S. at 107, 120 S.Ct. 2080 (citing
Furthermore,
It follows that the record before the Appeals Council constitutes part of the record upon which the final decision is based. The statute itself speaks to this point: When a claimant seeks court review of the Commissioner’s decision, the Commissioner “shall file a certified copy of the transcript of the record including the evidence upon which the findings and decision complained of are based.”
V
In sum, the statute provides that a claimant may obtain review of “any final decision of the Commissioner of Social Security.”
VACATED and REMANDED.
Notes
. Higginbotham also argues that the Appeals Council failed to apply proper legal standards when it failed to explain its weighing of Dr. Patel‘s statement, pursuant to the factors set forth in
. See Matthews v. Apfel, 239 F.3d 589, 593-94 (3d Cir.2001); Falge v. Apfel, 150 F.3d 1320, 1323 (11th Cir.1998); Cotton v. Sullivan, 2 F.3d 692, 696 (6th Cir.1993); Eads v. Sec’y of Dept. of Health & Human Servs., 983 F.2d 815, 817-18 (7th Cir.1993).
. See Perez v. Chafer, 77 F.3d 41, 44-45 (2d Cir.1996); O’Dell v. Shalala, 44 F.3d 855, 859 (10th Cir.1994); Ramirez v. Shalala, 8 F.3d 1449, 1452 (9th Cir.1993); Nelson v. Sullivan, 966 F.2d 363, 366 (8th Cir.1992); Wilkins v. Sec’y, Dept. of Health Human Servs., 953 F.2d 93, 96 (4th Cir.1991) (en banc).