History
  • No items yet
midpage
Helen Stein, 1 Widow and Administratrix of the Succession of Awtrey C. Gaudet, Deceased v. Sea-Land Services, Inc.
440 F.2d 1181
5th Cir.
1971
Check Treatment
PER CURIAM:

The original appellee Awtrey C. Gaudet was injured when he slipped and injured his back coming from a tier of cargo to the deck while working as a longshore foreman directing the loading of large trailer vans on the weather deck at the No. 3 hatch of the S. S. CLAIBORNE 2 on October 29, 1966, on the navigable waters of the Mississippi River in the city of New Orleans, Louisiana. He brought suit asserting that the accident and his resulting injury was caused by the unseaworthiness of the vessel in that it was not provided with ladders to go from tier to deck and further that the deck was greasy. The jury verdict by answers to special interrogatories found that the vessel was unseaworthy and that this was the proximate cause of Gaudet’s injury, that Gaudet was contributorily negligent and that his contributory negligence, expressed in percentage, contributed approximately 20% to his injury. The jury assessed the amount of the damages necessary to fairly compensate Gaudet for the injury at $175,000.00. *1182 After trial before the trial court and again on this appeal, the defendant-appellee raised questions attacking the jury verdict. These attacks were mounted by motions for directed verdict at the close of the plaintiff’s case, by motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, by motion for new trial, all on grounds of insufficiency of the evidence, and by motion for remittitur or alternatively for new trial on the ground of excessiveness of the verdict. The trial judge in an extensive (but oral and unreported) opinion sustained the verdict and the amount thereof and entered judgment for $140,000.00. We conclude that the trial judge correctly determined that the questions presented to him and on appeal to us represent no more than attempts to upset legitimate credibility choices of the jury. The judgment appealed from was right. It is

Affirmed.

Notes

2

. Owned and operated by Sea-Land Services, Inc., defendant-appellant.

Case Details

Case Name: Helen Stein, 1 Widow and Administratrix of the Succession of Awtrey C. Gaudet, Deceased v. Sea-Land Services, Inc.
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Date Published: Mar 29, 1971
Citation: 440 F.2d 1181
Docket Number: 30525
Court Abbreviation: 5th Cir.
AI-generated responses must be verified and are not legal advice.
Log In