Hayes v. ArchambaultHayes v. Archambault
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Wheeler
Two actions in case brought by Katherine and Harvey C. Hayes, Jr. to recover for personal injury and property damage arising out of an automobile accident which occurred November 27, 1962.
The writs in each case had an ad damnum of $500. After hearing the court found a verdict for $500 for each plaintiff with costs. Defendant’s counsel claimed an appeal to the Superior Court on March 21, 1964, which was denied on August 11, 1964.
*435 All questions of law raised by the denial of defendant’s claim of appeal were reserved and transferred by Sawyer, justice.
The defendant relies upon the following statute as the basis for the right to appeal to the Superior Court. “Civil causes. Either party may appeal from the judgment of a justice of a municipal court in a civil cause, to the superior court.” Laws 1957,
c.
244, which became
In effect at the time the appeal was claimed was the following pertinent statute: “Transfer to supreme court. In municipal courts located in cities and towns having a population of fifteen hundred or more, the finding of facts shall be final; but questions of law may be transferred to the supreme court in the same manner as from the superior court.”
Prior to the enactment of chapter 244, Laws 1957, the following statute relating to appeals was in effect. “Appeals. Except as herein otherwise provided, appeals may be taken from judgments ol municipal courts in the same manner and upon the same conditions as from justices of the peace.”
With the repeal of RSA ch. 501, the reference in
In 1950 the court in interpreting statutes practically identical in form as those now before us held that the words of what is now
The law does not favor repeal by implication if any other reasonable construction may avoid it. Gauthier v. Gosselin, 94 N. H. 496. “The occasion for employment of the rule must, be evidence of convincing force.” State v. Wilton Railroad, 89 N. H. 59, 61. No such compelling evidence exists here.
Exceptions overruled; judgment for the plaintiffs.
All concurred.