Hawkins v. RiemanHawkins v. Rieman
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- McMahan
This is an action by appellee against *129the appellant to recover upon three promissory notes, each for $500, and alleged to have been executed by the appellant to one Bertha Musser, and by her assigned in writing to appellee. The appellant answered: (1) General denial; (2) no consideration; (3) that appellee was not the real party in interest; (4) non est factum. Appellee filed a reply of general denial. Trial by jury. Verdict and judgment for appellee. The error assigned is the overruling of appellant’s motion for a new trial.
The next contention of appellant is that the evidence does not show any consideration. The circumstances surrounding the execution of these notes -are somewhat indefinite and vague. It does appear, however, that at one time the appellant conveyed a tract of land to Bertha Musser, or her husband, George Musser; that he after-wards foreclosed the mortgage against them, and bid in the land at sheriff’s sale, and afterwards assigned the certificate of purchase to John Hammond; that, prior to the conveyance of said land to the Mussers, the appellant had given George Musser a check for $370 with directions to turn the proceeds over to one Foster; that Musser, instead of doing so, cashed the check, retaining $20, and turned $350 of the proceeds over to said Hammond. Appellant, for some reason not disclosed by the evidence, desired to “get even” with Hammond. How he expected to get even is not explained by the evidence. He was, however, desirous of getting George Musser to sign an order directing Hammond to pay said $350 to appellant. Mr. Musser was not inclined to sign this order. Appellant, with the idea of getting his money back from Musser and Hammond, and to “get even” with somebody, was desirous of having Musser’s signature to this order and, according to the testimony of Mrs. Musser, he promised her that, if she would induce her husband to sign said order, he would give her enough money to redeem their home from the sheriff’s sale, and that her husband at her request and solicitation signed such order, and that thereupon’ appellant gave her the three notes in question, telling her that she could cash them, and that they would answer the same purpose as money. Appellant was a man of considerable wealth at that time, owning about 1,100 acres of land.
*131Appellant desired to secure the’ signature of Mr. Musser to the order, and he had a right to agree with Mrs. Musser to compensate her, if she would induce her husband to sign such order. He had a right to fix the value of such services, and such services, if performed, would be a valuable consideration, and a sufficient consideration, for the execution of notes in controversy, even though they called for a much larger amount of money than the appellant was receiving back from Musser and Hammond. Mrs. Musser testified concerning the agreement of appellant to give her the money to redeem her home from the sheriff’s sale and the circumstance connected with the execution of the notes. Appellant did not deny having had such a conversation with Mrs. Musser. He said if he had such a conversation he had forgotten about it.
Appellant also complains of the giving and the refusing to give certain instructions.
The court by instruction No. 20 informed the jury that if appellee failed to prove the material allegations of his complaint by a preponderance of the evidence, and that the appellant proved the second, third, or fourth paragraphs according to the rules of proof as stated in the instructions, their verdict should be for appellant. Taking the instructions as a whole, the jury was informed that the burden was on the appellee to prove the execution of the notes, and that, if he failed to do that, the verdict should have been for appellant.
There was no error in overruling the motion for a new trial. Judgment affirmed.