Harshbarger v. Pees (In re Harshbarger)Harshbarger v. Pees (In re Harshbarger)
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Kennedy
Appellants Robert and Mary Harshbarger (“debtors”) appeal the District Court’s decision to uphold the dismissal of their voluntary Chapter 13 bankruptcy petition for failure to submit a plan that satisfied the requirements of
I.
Mary Harshbarger is a vested participant in an ERISA-qualified profit sharing account (the “ERISA account”) maintained by her long-time employer, White Castle Systems, Inc. In 1985, Mrs. Harshbarger borrowed $6,400 from the ERISA account in order to put a down payment on a residence. This loan was to be repaid (and her full interest in the ERISA account restored) through monthly payroll deductions of $61.17. The ERISA account provides for a right of setoff, either in the future or immediately, if a participant fails to repay a loan.
In August of 1992, the Harshbargers filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy. When they submitted their Chapter 13 plan (the “Plan”),1 $3,855.54 remained to be paid on the loan against Mrs. Harshbarger’s ERISA account. Debtors’ Plan proposes to continue the $61.17 monthly payroll deductions and treat the ERISA-account loan as a separate class of unsecured debt that would be paid 100% ’’outside” of the Plan.2 In essence, the Plan exempts $61.17 per month from the estate’s disposable income. It proposes pro rata distribution of the funds included as disposable income to the remaining unsecured creditors, amounting to a dividend of approximately 40%.
The Trustee, Frank M. Pees, objected to the Plan, reasoning that under
The Bankruptcy Court ruled in favor of the Trustee. The District Court affirmed, ruling that only assets actually in the ERISA account, not future contributions or repayments, can be excluded from the bankruptcy estate under
II.
The central issue in this case is how debtors’ Plan should treat payments on a loan taken against an ERISA-qualified profit sharing account.
In response, the Trustee argues that only funds actually in an ERISA-qualified account are excluded from the estate under
III.
In reviewing bankruptcy decisions, we review the District Court’s conclusions of law de novo. In re Batie, 995 F.2d 85, 88 (6th Cir.1993).
In this case, a Chapter 13 Trustee objects to debtors’ Plan, which proposes to pay less than 100% to their unsecured creditors. In these circumstances
(1) If the trustee or the holder of an allowed unsecured claim objects to the confirmation of the plan, then the court may not approve the plan unless, as of the effective date of the plan—
[[Image here]]
(B) [T]he plan provides that all of the debtor’s projected disposable income to be received in the three-year period . . . will be applied to make payments under the plan.
(2) For purposes of this subsection, “disposable income” means income which is received by the debtor and which is not reasonably necessary to be expended—
(A) For the maintenance or support of the debtor or a dependent of the debt-or_
Debtors’ Plan proposes to deduct $61.17 per month from the disposable income available to pay unsecured creditors so that Mrs. Harshbarger may restore her full interest in the ERISA account. This expenditure may represent prudent financial planning, but it is not necessary for the “maintenance or support” of the debtors. See In re Scott, 142 B.R. 126, 133 (Bankr.E.D.Va.1992). Accordingly, the District Court was correct in affirming the decision to reject the Plan.
Debtors’ argument that
IV.
For the foregoing reasons we AFFIRM the judgment of the District Court.
Notes
. The actual plan at issue is the “Third Amended Chapter 13 Plan,” filed on Dec. 1, 1992.
. The entire $61.17 monthly payroll deduction is devoted to loan repayment. Mrs. Harshbarger is no longer contributing money to the ERISA account.
. Debtors argue as a threshold matter that the Trustee’s objection to the Plan was improperly before the Bankruptcy Court because it constituted the unauthorized practice of law by the Trustee. However, debtors did not raise this argument during the bankruptcy proceedings and the District Court refused to address it for that reason.
Debtors now argue that it was unnecessary for them to raise the issue below and urge this court to consider the argument on its merits. We decline to do so and instead follow the longstanding general rule of this circuit that “appellate courts are not to address issues not raised for the first time in the trial court.” In re Eagle-Picher Indus., 963 F.2d 855, 862-3 (6th Cir. 1992).