History
  • No items yet
midpage
Harper v. . Gray
4 N.C. 416
N.C.
1816
Check Treatment

We think a statement of this case will free it from difficulty.

Park's will is exhibited in Randolph County Court for probate; is carried from thence by way of appeal to the Superior Court; from that court is removed for trial to Rowan County, where it is tried by a jury, who find in favor of the will, and the same is directed to be recorded by the clerk of that court, and a copy directed to Randolph for recorded in that county. The petitioners charge that the probate was irregular, and petition Randolph County Court to set it aside, and order probate de novo. If the probate was irregular, application must be made to the court which erred, or to one of controlling power. The court of Randolph has committed no blunder which stands in the way, as by the appeal to the Superior Court a new trial was produced. It has no control over Rowan Superior Court; and, therefore, if it should direct the probate to be set aside and award a rehearing, it would be vain and nugatory. We think, therefore, the petition must be

Dismissed.

NOTE. — See Hodges v. Jasper, 12 N.C. 459.

Overruled: Sawyer v. Dozier, 27 N.C. 104.

(417)

Case Details

Case Name: Harper v. . Gray
Court Name: Supreme Court of North Carolina
Date Published: Jul 5, 1816
Citation: 4 N.C. 416
Court Abbreviation: N.C.
AI-generated responses must be verified and are not legal advice.
Your Notebook is empty. To add cases, bookmark them from your search, or select Add Cases to extract citations from a PDF or a block of text.