Harker v. GruhlHarker v. Gruhl
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Moran
On April 5, 1913, appellee, while attempting to cross Main street in the town of Hope, Indiana, was struck by appellant’s automobile, and she received severe injuries, which she alleges, in four paragraphs of complaint, were caused by the negligence of appellant, and for which she was awarded damages in the sum of $500.’
The jury trying the cause returned answers with the general verdict to forty-three interrogatories. The failure of the court to render judgment *179on the answers to interrogatories is the error relied upon for reversal by appellant. Many of the allegations of negligence charged are common to each paragraph of the complaint. Without attempting to state technically the theory of each paragraph of the complaint, the leading allegations of the first paragraph are that appellant at the time of the injury operated his automobile at a high and dangerous rate of speed in excess of ten miles per hour in a closely built-up portion of the town of Hope; the second paragraph alleges that appellee was without warning‘struck by appellant’s automobile, while it was being operated in a negligent manner by an inexperienced operator; the third paragraph alleges that appellee was struck by appellant’s automobile while it was being operated in a careless and negligent manner, at a rate of speed such as to endanger life and limb; and, the fourth paragraph alleges that appellant failed to warn appellee of the approach of the automobile, which would have prevented the injury.
By the answers to interrogatories, the jury found, among other things, that between the hours of nine and ten o’clock p. m., April 5, 1913, appellee attempted to cross Main street in an easterly direction, which street runs north and south through the town of Hope; that at the time she so started to cross, appellant was thirty-five feet to the south of her, and when she reached a point in the street nine feet from the sidewalk, she was struck by the automobile, which was proceeding to the north. The street was well lighted and the machine was equipped with lights, which shone brightly. That she looked for approaching vehicles before attempting to cross the street, but did not stop from the time she started to cross until she was struck by the automobile; that, if she had stopped after leaving the sidewalk, she could have seen the automobile at any *180point between where she left the sidewalk and where she was struck. It is very earnestly .urged by appellant that the answers to the interrogatories disclose that appellee did not exercise that degree of care that a reasonably prudent person would have exercised under the circumstances for her own safety; and that the facts thus found are so inconsistent with the general verdict that both cannot stand.
The general verdict, among other things, finds that appellant was an inexperienced operator, and that at the time of the injury he operated his automobile in a closely built-up portion of the town of Hope at a high and dangerous rate of speed; that he operated it at the rate of ten miles per hour, and at a rate of speed such as to endanger life and limb, in a careless and negligent manner, without giving any warning to travelers upon the street.
*181
*182
From the time appellee left the sidewalk until she was struck by the automobile, it is disclosed by the answers to interrogatories that she did not look for the approach of vehicles, but this fact of itself can not preclude a recovery as a matter of law. In Rump v. Woods (1912), 50 Ind. App. 347, 98 N. E. 369, the court in condemning an instruction, which informed the jury that a foot passenger was not required to look or listen continuously for the approach of automobiles, held that, as a general rule, it must be left for the jury to say what acts constitute ordinary care and what acts do not, and further added: “It would have been error for the court to *183say, as a matter of law, that ordinary care required appellee to look and listen constantly, and it wás also error to instruct the jury that ordinary prudence’ did not require him to do so.”
The conclusion we have reached necessitates an affirmance of the judgment. Judgment affirmed.
Note. — Reported in 111 N. E. 467. Rights and duties of pedestrians and of persons driving automobiles on highways, 4 Ann. Cas. 400; 13 Ann. Cas. 463 ; 21 Ann. Cas. 652; 108 Am. St. 215; notes, 25 L. R. A. (N. S.) 40; 38 L. R. A. (N. S.) 488; 1 L. R. A. (N. S.) 215; 3 L. R. A. (N. S.) 345; 20 L. R. A. (N. S.) 232; 51 L. R. A. (N. S.) 990; 28 Cyo 28, 37.