40 A.D.2d 769 | N.Y. App. Div. | 1972
In this action for the value of work, labor and services performed, the order, Supreme Court, Hew York County, entered May 24, 1972, denying defendant’s motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction is affirmed. Respondent shall recover of appellant $60 costs and disbursements of this appeal. Personal jurisdiction is grounded on CPLR 302 (subd. [a], par. 1) in that defendant through plaintiff, its agent, transacted business within this State. The retainer dated June 15, 1971 provides that plaintiff “will proceed to begin negotiations with the Welfare Island Development Corporation on behalf of our joint venture with The IHA Corporation toward the execution of a development agreement. We understand that you are leaving for Jerusalem on the 27th of June, and will be gone about six weeks. We understand that you will accomplish as much as possible between now and that date, and that we will arrange with you to transfer the work to another lawyer for conclusion at an appropriate time.” Welfare Island Development Corporation is a Hew York corporation. Plaintiff, a Hew York lawyer, did negotiate with Welfare in Hew York. During plaintiff’s absence, Joseph Winston, his associate attorney, also negotiated with Welfare in Hew York. All the “negotiations 6 * * on behalf” of defendant’s joint venture contemplated under the said retainer were had in Hew York. Clearly, the negotiations were by plaintiff and his associate as the agents for and in behalf of the defendant under the express provisions of the retainer. Defendant, therefore, through plaintiff and his associate as its agents, transacted business within this State within the meaning of CPLR 302 (subd. [a], par. 1). (De Nigris Assoc. v. Pacific Air Transp. Int., 38 A D 2d 363; Collateral Factors Corp. v. Meyers, 39 A D 2d 27.) Concur — Kupferman, McNally and Macken, JJ.; McGrivern, J. P., and Capozzoli, J., dissent in the following memorandum by Capozzoli, J.: I dissent and would reverse the order appealed from which denied defendant’s