2:14-ap-02030 | Bankr. S.D.W. Va. | Apr 16, 2014
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 1 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 30Main
Document Page 1 of 26
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF WEST VIRGINIA
AT CHARLESTON
DESIMONE HOSPITALITY SERVICES, LLC,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00063
(A. P. 2: 14-2036)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
SHAPE SHOP, INC.
and THELMA FAYS, LLC
d/b/a THELMA FAYS CAFE,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00038
(A.P. No. 2:14-2008)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.
and AMERICAN WATER WORKS
SERVICE COMPANY, INC.
and WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN
WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
NOEL HARDMAN and BRIAN VANNOY and
DIANA JOHNSON and COURTNEY HARPER and
KATHRYN CASTO and ROBERT STRINGER and
KIMBERLY LAPSLEY and TIMOTHY WILBURN and
MEAGAN KRASYK and HEIDI STRICKLEN and
MARK STRICKLEN and SONJA MARSHALL and
MARLENE DIAL and MARGARET SUE ZALENSKI and
JOSEPH ZALENSKI and JAMES PARSONS and
JANET ATKINS and KEITH ROEHL and
LISA ROEHL and CARL CHADBAND and
KRISTI CHADBAND and WILLIAM LIPSCOMB and
DEBRA LIPSCOMB and APRIL BARRIS and
ARMELIA PANNELL and LENOX CHANDLER and
1
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 2 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 31Main
Document Page 2 of 26
JOHNETTE JASPER and LATAUSHA TAYLOR and
KEVIN STUBBLEFIELD and MARTHA STUBBLEFIELD and
TAMMY PARSONS I
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00039
(A.P. No. 2:14-2009)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
MADDIE P. FIELDS,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00040
(A.P. No. 2:14-2010)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
RODOCO, INC. d/b/a DONUT CONNECTION, and
ALMOST HEAVEN BURGERS, INC.
d/b/a CHECKERS DRIVE-IN RESTAURANT
and HARGIS UNLIMITED, LLC
d/b/a KANAWHA CITY COIN LAUNDRY
and MELANIE MARTIN
and MEGAN SPEARS
and SYRRA SALON LLC
and PAUL KIRK
d/b/a BARE KNUCKLES TATTOO SHOP,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00041
(A.P. No. 2:14-2011)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
2
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 3 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 32Main
Document Page 3 of 26
EG & K INC.
and RUSTY A. CARPENTER,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00042
(A.P. No. 2:14-2012)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY, and
JOHN DOE CORPORATION 1 THROUGH 5
and JOHN DOE,
Defendants.
SUSAN K. DYER
individually and on behalf of
all others similar situated,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00043
(A.P. No. 2:14-2013)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
5 CORNERS CAFE, LLC and
THE VINTAGE BARBER SHOP and
JUSTIN A. AMOS,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00044
(A.P. No. 2:14-2014)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Defendant.
3
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 4 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 33Main
Document Page 4 of 26
CANDICE HENRY MAHOOD
and CARRIE ANN SAMUELS
and KATHERINE ELLA GRUBB
and Ia:LLI OLDHAM
and ELIZABETH GRUBB,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00045
(A.P. No. 2:14-2015)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
DENNIS FARRELL and
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
and OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF
UNSECURED CREDITORS FOR
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Defendants.
VON HARVEY,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00046
(A.P. No. 2:14-2016)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER and
AMERICAN WATER WORKS SERVICE COMPANY, INC. and
OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF UNSECURED CREDITORS FOR
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Defendants.
4
Case 2:14-ap-02030 Doc 16 Filed 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14 15:52:04 Desc Main
Document Page 5 of 26
GRUMPY’ S GRI LLE, LLC and
J OE FAZI O’ S RESTAURANT, I NC. ,
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 6 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 35Main
Document Page 6 of 26
JOHN NELSON and
WANDA TRIBBIE,
an individual and as representative
of and al ong wi t h “ ot her st yl i st s
or barbers, located in Kanawha,
Putnam, Boone, Jackson, Cabell, Clay
Lincoln, Loqan and Roane Counties
similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00050
(A.P. No. 2:14-2022)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
ltUPPEL LLC
d/b/a DREAM TANK
d/b/a CAPITOL DOME BAR & GRILLE
and REEMA FAMILY HAIRSTYLING,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00051
(A.P. No. 2:14-2023)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.
and WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER,
Defendants.
6
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 7 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 36Main
Document Page 7 of 26
SHANNON LARWA and
SHANNON’ S SUI TE SALON, LLC
d/ b/ a SHANNON’ S SUI TE SALON and
JENNIFER SCHOOLCRAFT and INNOV8 SALON, LLC
d/b/a INNOV8 SALON, LLC and
ALEX MORGADO and MORGADO DESIGN, LLC
d/b/a MORGADO DESIGN and JOHN PATRICK BURGESS, DDS and
MADIGAN RAE BURGESS, DDS, individually and on behalf of
all others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00052
(A.P. No. 2:14-2024)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
CORNELLISUS D. CHRISTIAN,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00053
(A.P. No. 2:14-2025)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Defendant.
JOHN LEVIN and
LOUISA LEVIN
on behalf of themselves and
all others situated,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00054
(A.P. No. 2:14-2026)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendants.
7
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 8 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 37Main
Document Page 8 of 26
GRAZIANO INVESTMENTS, INC. and
CATERING UNLIMITED, INC. and
SHELTON’ S OF KANAWHA CI TY, LLC and
ERIC BOOTH individually and on behalf of
others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00055
(A.P. No. 2:14-2027)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Defendant.
HAIR WE ARE, INC . ,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00056
(A.P. No. 2:14-2029)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC. and
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER,
Defendants.
JUNE GURSKI
and JOHN DOE BUSINESS OWNER,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No. 2:14-00057
(A.P. No. 2:14-2030)
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.
and WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN
WATER COMPANY
and JOHN DOE CORPORATION
1 THROUGH 5
and JOHN DOE,
Defendants.
8
CaseCase
2:14-ap-02030 DocDocument
2:14-cv-14845 16 Filed1-3
04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 Page 9 of15:52:04
26 PageiDDesc
#: 38Main
Document Page 9 of 26
LITTLE BO PEEP DAYCARE and
KIDS R US DAYCARE and
PAULINE'S HOUSE OF CURLS and
JANE GURSKI and
PAULA MILLER, individually and on behalf
of others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00058
(A. P. 2: 14-2031)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
BOBBY L. TUCKER and
REBA TUCKER, his wife,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00059
(A.P. 2:14-2032)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
MAID IN THE USA, INC., doinq business as
Maid to Perfection of Charleston,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00060
(A. P. 2: 14-2030)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
9
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 10 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 39
Document Page 10 of 26
OTIS TUCKER and
DANETTE TUCKER, his wife,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00061
(A. P. 2: 14-2034)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
THE TOWN OF BUFFALO,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00062
(A. P. 2: 14-2035)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
RONNIE ALLEN BRISCOE and
DENISE EVON BRISCOE,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00064
(A. P. 2: 14-2037)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
DEBORAH J. HEDRICK I
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00065
(A. P. 2: 14-2038)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
10
Case 2:14-ap-02030 Doc 16 Filed 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14 15:52:04 Desc Main
Document Page 11 of 26
Case 2:14-ap-02030 Doc 16 Filed 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14 15:52:04 Desc Main
Document Page 12 of 26
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 13 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 42
Document Page 13 of 26
CHRISTOPHER M. DEWEESE and
LORI L. DEWEESE,
Plaintiffs,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00072
(A. P. 2: 14-2045)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
CHRISTOPHER JORDAN,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00073
(A. P. 2: 14-2046)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
SANDYLOU & TIFFANY 2, LLC, a West Virginia corporation,
doinq business as Anqaleno's Pizza,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00074
(A.P. 2:14-2047)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
MARGIE JORDAN I
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00075
(A. P. 2: 14-2048)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
13
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 14 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 43
Document Page 14 of 26
NICK KONNOVITCH,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00076
(A. P. 2: 14-2049)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY and
FREEDOM INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Defendants.
MISTY HARRIS,
Plaintiff,
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00077
(A. P. 2: 14-2050)
WEST VIRGINIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY,
Defendant.
MARY BARBER
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00078
(A.P. No. 2:14-2051)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
WARREN SHAMBLIN and
JESSICA SHAMBLIN,
Plaintiffs
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00079
(A.P. No. 2:14-2052)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
14
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 15 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 44
Document Page 15 of 26
BUFFALO VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPARTMENT, INC.,
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00080
(A.P. No. 2:14-2053)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
TRENT FORBIS and
LESLI FORBIS
Plaintiffs
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00081
(A.P. No. 2:14-2054)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
EJ&K ENTERPRISES, LLC and
SOUTH HILLS MARKET & CAFE, LLC
Plaintiffs
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00082
(A.P. No. 2:14-2055)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
JASON BROGAN
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00083
(A.P. No. 2:14-2056)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
15
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 16 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 45
Document Page 16 of 26
AM & GH LLC,
doinq business as
Grano, and L AND G FOODS, INC. and
SAHARA CATERING & RESTAURANT, INC. , and
MADELINES CAFE INC. , and
MOUND CLEANERS, INC. , and
NEXUS ATHLETIC CLUBS, INC. , and
CITY FITNESS, INC., and
NAUTILUS FITNESS CENTER, INC., and
KINETIX FITNESS LLC, and
PAUL WALTON, JR. , and
TABETHA PEIROS and
BART A. ROBERTS and
KRIST I MADDOX,
and all others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00084
(A.P. No. 2:14-2057)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
FALBO & MONDAY, PLLC,
and similiarly situated,
Plaintiffs
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00085
(A.P. No. 2:14-2058)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
16
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 17 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 46
Document Page 17 of 26
J. E., individually
and on behalf of their minor child,
ICE.,
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00086
(A.P. No. 2:14-2059)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
MELISSA JEAN MEDLEY,
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00087
(A.P. No. 2:14-2060)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
RICHARD GRAVELY,
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00088
(A.P. No. 2:14-2061)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
17
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 18 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 47
Document Page 18 of 26
SCOTT MILLER and
BAR 101, LLC, and
ICHIBAN, individually and on
behalf of all others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00089
(A.P. No. 2:14-2062)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
MARK STRICKLAND,
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00090
(A.P. No. 2:14-2063)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
DANIEL CLEVE STEWART I
Plaintiff
v. Misc. Action No.: 2:14-00091
(A.P. No. 2:14-2064)
WEST VIRGINIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Defendant
18
Case 2:14-ap-02030
Case 2:14-cv-14845Doc 16 Filed1-3
Document 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14
Filed 04/16/14 15:52:04
Page 19 of Desc
26 PageiD Main
#: 48
Document Page 19 of 26
I135 B.R. 788" date_filed="1992-01-10" court="D. Maryland" case_name="Travelers Insurance Co. v. Goldberg">135 B.R. 788, 792 (D. Md. 1992). While
the bankruptcy court may be uniquely qualified to
conduct pre-trial matters in some core proceedings, in
other cases such a referral would be a "futile detour,
requiring substantial duplication of judicial effort."
Compare Travelers Ins. Co., 135 B.R. 788" date_filed="1992-01-10" court="D. Maryland" case_name="Travelers Insurance Co. v. Goldberg">135 B.R. at 792-93 with
City Fire Equipment Co. v. Ansul Fire Protection
Wormald U.S., Inc., 125 B.R. 645" date_filed="1989-12-07" court="N.D. Ala." case_name="City Fire Equipment Co. v. Ansul Fire Protection Wormald U.S., Inc.">125 B.R. 645, 649 (N.D. Ala. 1989)
(bankruptcy court has the authority and is uniquely
qualified to supervise discovery and decide pre-trial
issues). This type of pragmatic decision is best
left to the district court and we remand for that
court to consider the Committee's request.
Stansbury, 13 F.3d at 128.
The court concludes that the plaintiffs in the
aforementioned adversary proceedings appear entitled to a jury
trial as requested in each of the actions covered by the motions
for withdrawal of reference. It further does not appear that
any party desires to consent to the bankruptcy court conducting
jury trials in these matters pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 157(e), nor
that such right to a jury trial has been somehow waived by the
claims process to date. Inasmuch as many of these related-to
cases involve traditional personal injury tort claims of a non-
25
Case 2:14-ap-02030 Doc 16 Filed 04/16/14 Entered 04/24/14 15:52:04 Desc Main
Document Page 26 of 26
John T. Copenhaver, Jr.
United States District Judge
(“
. . . .”).