Gulp, C. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. HicksGulp, C. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Hicks
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Hald
This suit grows out of the death of appellees’ son, who, while employed as a brakeman, was killed in the derailment of a freight train upon appellant’s line of road, in the month of September, 1911. This is the third appeal in this case. The first trial resulted in a judgment for $5,500, and the second for $7,000. A remittitur of $3,500 was required by the trial court and entered in the last trial. Upon both appeals the judgments were affirmed upon condition that appellees would remit all but $1,100. Upon appellees’ refusal to enter such remittitur, the judgments were reversed and remanded.
*779 Appellees alleged that the train upon which their son was employed was derailed and wrecked by the negligence of appellant in operating said train at a rapid and dangerous rate of speed over a track alleged to he defective; that if their son’s death did not result from the negligence of appellant in this respect, then his death was caused by the negligence of defendant’s train crew in abandoning and leaving him pinned and buried under the wreckage.
Appellant answered by general and special exception, general denial, and pleaded specially that the accident out of which the suit arose was not caused from any negligence of appellant company, but was occasioned by one of the ordinary incidents of that character of train service; . that the deceased was violating one of the rules of appellant company in that he was riding on top of a box car when he should have been in the cab of the engine; and set up the defenses of contributory negligence and assumed risk. In a trial before a jury there was a verdict in favor of appellees in the sum of $2,750.
“I judge it was about twenty-five or thirty-minutes—twenty, or somewhere in that neighborhood—before the other men returned that went away. I never timed them. While the train crew was gone we moved the brickbats, and stuff from around him, and tried to cut some iron rods that had Ms legs between his ankles and knees, and could not cut them with an axe, and did not have any tools to cut the rods loose from him enough to get him out, and we did not get him out until they got back with some wrenches.”
The objection made to this testimony is that it was immaterial and irrelevant.
Appellant further insists that the court erred in refusing to permit it to prove by its witness B. B. Mason, who had qualified as an expert, that it was safer for a man to ride in the cab of an engine than it was for him to ride on the top of a box ear. If admitted, this testimony would not, as applicable to all cases, have been true. In the event of a head-end collision, or a derailment of the engine, which more frequently occurs, most any other place would have been safer than the cab of the engine. If the performance of his duties by deceased at the time of the wreck required his presence upon the top of the cars, clearly the evidence would not have been admissible. As briefed, the assignment does not show the relevancy of this testimony. We gather from the record that the accident occurred less than three miles from the station of Celeste. The burden, being upon appellant to show that his proper place was in the engine cab at that time, was not discharged, as shown by the assignment. Appellant’s rule No. 418, governing employes, introduced by appellees, is as follows:
“Freight brakemen must be on top of their trains when approaching and passing stations, railroad crossings at grade, drawbridges, and when descending steep grades.”
Finding no reversible error, the judgment is affirmed.
eSjb^For other cases see same topic and KEY-NUMBER in all Key-Numbered Digests and Indexes