Guertin v. MombleauGuertin v. Mombleau
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Shope
delivered the opinion of the Court:
This was ejectment to recover certain lots in Achille Chiniqui’s addition to the village of St. Anne, in Kankakee county. The evidence preserved in the record shows a patent from the United States to George W. Cassady, and a deed from him to Mitchell Allen. The next deed in the chain of title is from Mitchell Allain to Ambrose Allain. This deed was objected to, as not conveying the title vested by the conveyance from Cassady, in Mitchell Allen. It was held in the case of Chiniqui v. Catholic Bishop, 41 Ill. 153, that these names were idem sonans. That they are similar in sound when pronounced in ordinary conversation seems clear, and we have no disposition to review the grounds of that holding.
The record showed the title of Ambrose Allain, under said conveyances, to the N. half of the S. E. qr. of Sec. 4, was sold at sheriff’s sale under a judgment in favor of Lowe, and against said Ambrose Allen, and a deed was made by the sheriff thereunder to Achille Chiniqui for the same. Achille Chiniqui laid out an addition to the village of St. Anne, which embraced land on the said N. ½ of said S. E. ¼ of said Sec. 4, and also on the N. ½ of the S. ½ of said quarter section. That is, blocks 1 and 2, and all of blocks 3, 4, 5 and 6, except 39 feet off the north end of the north tier of lots, are upon the N. ½ of the S. ½ of said south-east quarter, while the 39 feet excepted and other blocks are upon the N. ½ of said S. E. qr. Under this state of facts, the deed from Achille Chiniqui to Charles A. Chiniqui, and the deed of the latter to Lucy Chiniqui, conveyed no title to any part of the lots or blocks situated on the N. ½ of the S. ½ of said south-east one-fourth, but was good as to the lots and blocks on the N. ½ of said quarter.
While the title thus stood, the N. ½ of said S. E. ¼ in Lucy Chiniqui, she, joined by her husband, Achille Chiniqui, executed, acknowledged and delivered their warranty deed for the lots in controversy to Judson, Tenney and Young.
By mesne conveyances, whatever right Judson, Tenney and Young acquired became vested in the plaintiff.
Objection is made to the deed of Lucy Chiniqui and her husband to Judson, Tenney and Young, on the ground that the acknowledgment appears to have been taken in Cook county by a notary public of Du Page county. This was, we think, authorized by the ninth section of the Notaries Public Act, in force July 1, 1872.
The principal contention, however, is, in respect of whether the title subsequently acquired by Charles A. Chiniqui inured to Lucy Chiniqui, his grantee, and those succeeding to her right. She acquired no title by the conveyance from Charles A. Chiniqui to herself, to the N. ½ of the S. ½ of said S. E. ¼ Sec. 4, the title remaining in Ambrose Allain. In 1875, after her conveyance to Judson, Tenney and Young, said Ambrose Allain conveyed N. ½ of the S. ½ of the S. E. ¼ of said section 4 to Boudreau, who, in 1877, conveyed the same to Charles A. Chiniqui. The latter having, by his warranty deed of June 16, 1871, covenanted to warrant the title to the lots situated upon said tract, to said Lucy Chiniqui, the title or interest acquired by said Charles A. therein would have inured to her, if she had not made her warranty deed to Judson, Tenney and Young. It is insisted that such after-acquired title would not inure to the benefit of her grantees. It is said that the warranty deed of Lucy Chiniqui and her husband was void, so far as it attempted to convey lots to which she had no title, and being void
The effect is simply to give a deed, otherwise void as a conveyance, because the grantor has no title, the validity which makes it operative when the grantor subsequently acquires title. The statute declares that the effect of such a deed shall be to pass any after-acquired title by the grantor, the same as if he was seized of it when the deed was made. We are of opinion that the after-acquired title by Charles A. Chiniqui, by means of the conveyance from Bondreau, inured to the grantees of Lucy Chiniqui. Her title having by operation of her deed under the statute passed to her grantees, she had no title to convey, and her deed, dated April 20, 1882, to the defendant constituted no defense to the action.
The defendant also relies upon the sixth section of the Limitation Act as to some of the lots in controversy. Appellant did not acquire color of title until April 20, 1882, less than seven years before the bringing of this suit. He can not rely upon the deeds to Charles A. or Lucy Chiniqui, as color of title, for the reason that whatever interest they acquired by or under said deeds, eo instamti inured to the benefit of their grantees, who took the same as if named in such deed as grantees. They at no time acquired claim and color of title in good faith, as against their prior grantees.
The three requisites of color of title acquired in good faith, possession and payment of taxes for seven successive years not concurring, the bar of the statute was not complete. Stearns v. Gittings, 23 Ill. 388; Morrison et al. v. Norman et al., 47 id. 477.
After the appeal in this case was perfected, appellee obtained leave of the Circuit Court to amend the bill of exceptions, and the same was amended accordingly, and on certiorari was sent up duly certified. Appellant perfected a separate appeal from the order allowing the amendment, which is docketed as No. 2 of the term, and moved in this court to strike such amended record
Finding no error in the record, the judgment of the Circuit Court is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.