Grubb v. Johnson Oil Refining Co.Grubb v. Johnson Oil Refining Co.
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Osborn
This action was brought by plaintiff, Johnson Oil Refining Company, against Mildred Grubb, county treasurer of Pawnee county, to recover taxes paid under protest. Judgment was for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.
Essential facts are undisputed. Plaintiff failed to file its 1944 list or return of’ its personal property for taxation until after May 1, 1944. The county assessor of Pawnee county accepted the valuation of plaintiff’s property as shown in said list, but added to such valuation 10 per cent of the amount thereof as a penalty under the provisions of 68 O.S. 1941
Defendant contends that the penalty provided in
“If any personal property is not listed on or before May 1st of any year, when such property is assessed there shall be added as an additional mandatory penalty ten per centum (10%) of the value of such property. If the county assessor fails, neglects or refuses to add the penalty of one dollar ($1.00) and the ten per centum (10%) valuation penalty, as hereinbefore provided, he shall be liable on his official bond for the amount of said penalty.”
The fact that the assessor accepted the valuation placed upon its personal property by plaintiff, and did not change or increase the amount thereof, or that he did not, after March 1st, proceed to make an investigation and list the value of the property of plaintiff, as he was authorized to do by section 15.18, does not relieve plaintiff of the penalty imposed. The penalty is not imposed to reimburse the county or the assessor for extra work done by the assessor, as was formerly the case under the statute providing for the imposition of the $1 penalty (see Staley v. Board of County Commissioners, 72 Okla. 147, 179 P. 465), but was imposed for the purpose of enforcing the listing of property by the taxpayer.
Plaintiff asserts that under the provisions of section 15.18, the assessor, if personal property is not listed with him on or before March 1st of any year, is required to ascertain and estimate from the best information obtainable the amount and value of such property and to list and assess the same in the name of the owner, if such owner be known, and that before said assessment becomes final he must mail a copy of it to the owner, who has ten days thereafter to be heard on the valuations. He says that in view of the provisions of this section it is absurd to contend that the assessor, by simply failing to take such action as is provided therein and waiting until May 1st, may then penalize a taxpayer, who lists his property after that date, 10 per cent without notice to him.
We think the two sections are not, when properly construed, inconsistent, and that compliance by the assessor with the provisions of section 15.18 does not preclude him from imposing the penalty provided by
Plaintiff further asserts that under the facts in the instant case the assessor did not assess the property of plaintiff, as the term “assess” is used in
Plaintiff also asserts that
“Should any taxpayer neglect, fail or refuse to make a proper itemization of his property in any county, or neglect, fail or refuse to furnish any other information required by this section, or the preceding section, it shall be the duty of the County Assessor or the County Board of Equalization to ascertain, from the best information obtainable, the value of the property of such taxpayer, and as a penalty, shall add ten per cen-tum (10%) of the value thereof so ascertained, provided that the penalty shall not be applied until the taxpayer shall have had ten days notice of the intention to apply the penalty and an opportunity to be heard.”
The trial court resolved this contention against the plaintiff, and, we think, correctly. By its plain language the penalty imposed by
Defendant next contends that the trial court erred in holding that the penalty provision of
*436We think that the action.of the assessor in imposing the penalty upon plaintiff was not subject to review or correction ■ by the county equalization board, and that plaintiff, in paying the taxes under protest and bringing this action to recover taxes which it contends were improperly assessed, pursued the proper remedy.
68 O.S. 1941
“It shall be the duty of said Boards, and they shall have the authority, (a) to equalize, correct and adjust the assessed valuation of real and personal property, by raising or lowering the valuation of the property, real or personal, of any taxpayer, to conform to the fair cash value thereof, as defined by law, (b) to add omitted property, and (c) to cancel assessments of property not taxable.”
That section does not authorize the board to set aside or annul the penalty provided by
But we think the contention of defendant that the statute imposing the penalty does not violate the due process clause of the State and Federal Constitutions is well taken, and that the trial court erred in holding the statute unconstitutional. In the instant case plaintiff was given notice by the statute itself that if it failed to file its return on or before May 1st, it was the mandatory duty of the county assessor to impose the penalty. Plaintiff was charged with knowledge of the law, and where the statute fixed the date after which the penalty would be applied, that -was sufficient notice, and no additional notice by the assessor was required. Cooley on Taxation (4th Ed.) vol. 3, § 1127.
In Stamper v. Schwartz, 191 Okla. 308, 129 P. 2d 587, we said that where the statute notified the taxpayer of the time within which he could pay his tax, no demand for payment of taxes was necessary, it being the duty of the taxpayer to attend the treasurer’s office’ and pay his taxes in accordance with the command of the statute. So in the instant case it was the duty of the taxpayer to file his return within the time specified by law in order to avoid, the imposition of the penalty, and upon his failure to do so the penalty applied.
Furthermore, the taxpayer could, if he considered the penalty improperly or wrongfully imposed upon him, proceed in accordance with 68 O.S. 1941
“The plaintiff further contends that by reason of the failure of the county assessor to publish notice as required by section 9664, supra, if he was required to pay the taxes assessed against his’ property by the county assessor he would be deprived of his property without due process of law. We cannot agree with this contention. Due process of law is shown when opportunity is conferred to invoke the equal protection of the law by judicial proceedings appropriate for the purpose and adequate to secure the end and objects sought to be attained. Chicago, R. & Q.R. Co. v. State ex rel. City of Omaha, 47 Neb. 549, 66 N. W. 624, 41 L.R.A. 481, 53 Am. St. Rep. 557.”
In Re Thomas’ Estate, 192 Okla. 409, 136 P. 2d 929, we said:
*437“In respect to taxation, the ‘due process’ provision of the Constitution is satisfied if at some stage of the proceeding, either before or after assessment, the party assessed has notice thereof and an adequate opportunity to be heard either before a judicial tribunal or a board of assessment.”
In Security Trust & S. V. Co. v. Lexington, 203 U.S. 323, 51 L. Ed. 204, 27 S. Ct. 87, the Supreme Court of the United States held that where the procedure of the state gave the taxpayer an opportunity to be heard upon the validity of the tax in a proceeding to enjoin its collection, the requirement of due process was satisfied.
The cases cited by plaintiff, such as Central of Georgia R. Co. v. Wright, 207 U.S. 127, 52 L. Ed. 134, 28 S. Ct. 47, deal with state statutes under which the taxpayer was hot afforded an opportunity to be heard as to the validity or invalidity of the tax. They are neither controlling nor persuasive on the question herein involved.
Penalties such as the one provided in
We hold that the statute is not viola-tive of either the State or Federal Constitution; that the penalty provided in section 15.12 is not unreasonable or arbitrary, and that it was properly imposed upon plaintiff by the county assessor as his mandatory duty under the plain provisions of the statute.
Reversed, with directions to render judgment for defendant.
HURST, C.J., DAVISON, V.C.J., and BAYLESS, WELCH, CORN, and GIBSON, JJ., concur.