68 W. Va. 714 | W. Va. | 1911
This is a writ of error to a judgment, quashing a writ of soire facias to revive a judgment, issued by the clerk of the circuit court of Braxton county, at the instance of I. TI. Great-house, guardian for W. 0. Morrison and Stella M. Morrison.
The judgment was rendered in favor of Greathouse, guardian as aforesaid, and against G. H. Morrison, W. F. Morrison and W. P. Newlon. One of these, G. PI. Morrison, having died, R. F. Morrison had been appointed executor of his will and qualified. Service of the writ upon the two surviving debtors and the executor was commanded and it. was served on them, but the monition thereof was that judgment would be sought against the survivors and the testator, one of the deceased debtors, not against the personal representative. The action of the court stands upon the assumption of a defect as to parties, non-joinder or misjoinder of the executor.
The first question is the construction of the writ to determine whether he was really joined. As no execution, the real object of the writ, was asked as to him, we think he was not, although it was directed to be served, upon him, and was so served. This seems to have been done for the purpose of enabling him to appear and defend, but not for the purpose of taking execution against him, upon the assumption of an interest in the subject matter, conferring such right of defense. He is not a real party to the writ. His status is analogous to that of a defendant in a summons in an equity suit against whom nothing is alleged in the bill. In our opinion, the real and only defendants are the judgment debtors. One of these being dead the prayer for execution against him may be treated as sur-plusage.
A scire facias against the surviving debtors only lies, as it would against only the personal representative of the deceased one. “Where a judgment is rendered against two, and then one
We, therefore, reverse the judgment, overrule the motion to quash, and, as the defendants are entitled to plead nul tiel record or any other proper matter of defense, remand the ease.
Reversed and Remanded.