Goodnow v. Bond, 59 N.H. 150

Goodnow v. Bond

59 N.H. 150 | N.H. | 1879

The writing declared on is an agreement to pay the taxes of a third person, and is not a promissory note. The facts do not support the common money counts, and a special declaration is necessary. Knight v. Knight,16 N.H. 107. The amendment alleging a consideration does not introduce a new cause of action, is necessary, and was properly allowed. Greenleaf v. Burbank, 13 N.H. 454; Gove v. Newton, 58 N.H. 359. The written contract contained a promise of the defendant to pay the plaintiff the debt of a third person, and was a sufficient memorandum, within the meaning of the statute of frauds of this state, without reciting a consideration for the promise. Britton v. Angier, 48 N.H. 420; Packard v. Richardson,17 Mass. 122. The defendant's signature being admitted, the writing was competent proof of the promise, and the consideration could be proved by extraneous evidence.

If there had been no memorandum, there would have been a question whether the consideration, alleged and proved, was sufficient to take the case out of the statute, — whether it was distinct from and independent of the original debt, and passed between these parties. Allen v. Thompson,10 N.H. 32; Robinson v. Gilman, 43 N.H. 485, 492; Britton v. Angier,48 N.H. 420, 425. In Gove v. Newton, supra, no question was raised upon the statutes of frauds. It was probable, although not alleged, that Newton (as administrator) derived a benefit from Gove's forbearance. And in this case it is probable that, upon facts not stated, the defendant would be liable on the same ground without a memorandum. But the memorandum being sufficient to satisfy the statute, the damage to the plaintiff in refraining from levying on Grout's property, at the defendant's request, was a sufficient consideration for the defendant's promise to pay Grout's taxes. Bank v. Colcord, 15 N.H. 119, 124; Gove v. Newton, supra; Jennison v. Stafford, 1 Cush. 168. The plaintiff can recover.

Case discharged.

CLARK, J., did not sit: the others concurred.