Gomeau v. ForrestGomeau v. Forrest
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Loiselle
The original action herein, alleging that the negligence of an owner and an operator of a truck caused the injuries and death of two-year-old Matthew Gomeau, was brought by his estate.
The third-party plaintiffs claim that the trial court erred in concluding that (1) contribution is not allowed between joint tortfeasors in Connecticut; (2) intrafamily tort immunity is an effective bar to the third-party action; and (3) a parent’s negligent supervision of a child is not actionable in this state. Because the issue of contribution is dis-positive of this appeal, we do not address the other two arguments.
The third-party plaintiffs argue that the enactment of
The common law of this state, unlike that of a number of other jurisdictions, does not permit contribution between joint tortfeasors.
Fox
v.
Fox,
168 Conn. 592, 595, 362 A.2d 854 (1975);
Rose
v.
Heisler,
118 Conn. 632, 633, 174 A. 66 (1934);
Caviote
v.
Shea,
116 Conn. 569, 575, 165 A. 788 (1933); 18 Am. Jur. 2d, Contribution § 33. See
In 1973,
The third-party plaintiffs claim that even if it is found that the legislature did not intend to include a modification of the rule against contribution, it in fact did so by the language it used. It is true that in the interpretation of statutes, the intent of the legislature is to be found not in what it meant to say, but in what it did say. Sillman v. Sillman, 168 Conn. 144, 148, 358 A.2d 150 (1975); Schwab v. Zoning Board of Appeals, 154 Conn. 479, 482, 226 A.2d 506 (1967).
The third-party plaintiffs argue that the use of the phrase “any person” as delineating who can sue under
In their cross-complaint, the third-party plaintiffs alleged that the third-party defendants were the primary and direct cause of Matthew’s death and requested damages by way of indemnification. “[IJndemnity involves a claim for reimbursement in full from one on whom a primary liability is claimed to rest, while contribution involves a claim for reimbursement of a share of a payment neces
Since this is the case, our conclusion that
There is no error.
In this opinion the other judges concurred.
Notes
“[General Statutes] See. 52-572h. negligence actions, doctrines applicable, (a) In causes of action based on negligence, contributory negligence shall not bar recovery in an action by any person or Ms legal representative to recover damages resulting from injury to persons or damage to property, if such negligence was not greater than the combined negligence of the person or persons against whom recovery is sought, but any damages allowed shall be diminished in the proportion of the percentage of negligence attributable to the person recovering, (b) In any action to which this section is applicable, the instructions to the jury given by the court shall include an explanation of the effect on awards and liabilities of the percentage of negligence found by the jury to be attributable to each party. (c) The legal doctrines of last clear chance and assumption of risk in actions to which this section is applicable are abolished.”
It is noteworthy that the two law review articles that analyzed in depth