Girhard v. YostGirhard v. Yost
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Stone
delivered the opinion of the court:
Appellee filed a petition in the circuit court of Jasper county to contest the election of appellant to the office of county superintendent of schools in that county. On hearing the court found that appellee was elected to said office and that the certificate of election issued to appellant was null and void. Appellant brings the cause here for review.
Appellant’s first assignment of error is the denial by the court of his motion to dismiss appellee’s petition for want of jurisdiction. This motion was based on the ground, among others, that the petition was not properly verified.
The petition avers that appellee, the petitioner, is a legally qualified elector of Jasper county and had resided in the county for more than one year then last past. It
The petition was signed by appellee and contained the following as a verification thereof: “C. E. Girhard being first duly sworn, on his oath deposes and says that he is the person whose name is subscribed to the foregoing petition and that he is acquainted with the contents thereof. Affiant further states that the matters and things therein contained are true to the best of his knowledge, information and belief.” This affidavit was signed and sworn to before L. W. Kellogg, notary public. Appellant contends that this affidavit is not sufficient to give the court jurisdiction.
The right to contest an election is statutory and the procedure by statute prescribed must be strictly followed. The case is neither an action at law nor in equity. Section 116 of the Elections act provides that after the filing of the contest
In Christian Hospital v. People, 223 Ill. 244, an affidavit stating that the facts in the pleading “are true except so far as they are stated on information and belief,” was held defective in that it failed to distinguish between matters stated on the pleader’s own knowledge and those stated on information and belief. Such an affidavit, instead of referring the court to the pleadings to ascertain what is submitted on information and belief, refers the court to the mind of the pleader for what he intended to assert on information and belief. In that case an affidavit in substance in the form used in the case of Farrell v. Heiberg was approved.
In Bramstaedt v. Indian Boundary Sanitary District, 332 Ill. 339, it was again held that it is necessary that petitions to contest an election be verified by affidavit, and in that case an affidavit stating that the petitioners had heard the petition read, knew the contents thereof and that same is true of their own knowledge except as it is therein stated to be on information and belief, and that as to those matters they believe them to be true, was held a sufficient affidavit. It was also in that case held that a petition filed without being sworn to in the manner required by the statute should be stricken from the files on motion. This rule was again adhered to in Hulse v. Nash, 332 Ill. 500.
In this case the entire petition is on direct statements of fact and contains no allegations on information and belief. The verification goes to the entire petition. The affidavit
Counsel for appellee cite the case of Jackson v. Winans, 287 Ill. 382, as authority for his contention that a petition to contest an election which is verified on information and belief is sufficiently verified. That case is not in conflict with the cases herein cited as it does not show that the verification was entirely on information and belief. The opinion in that case cites and follows Farrell v. Heiberg, supra. We know of no case holding that a verification solely on information and belief is a good verification to a bill in chancery where certain of its allegations are necessarily within the knowledge of the pleader.
The verification of the petition to contest the election of appellant was not sufficient to give the court jurisdiction and the motion to dismiss the petition should have been sustained. For this error the judgment of the circuit court is reversed and the cause remanded to that court, with directions to dismiss the petition.
Reversed and remanded, with directions.