Gill v. StolowGill v. Stolow
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Lumbard
On September 1, 1955, I filed an opinion granting plaintiff’s motion to strike the answer of defendant partnership and enter default judgment against it pursuant to
I am also of the opinion that the objections raised against holding the partnership in default for Mr. Stolow’s nonappearance are without substance.
*510 The Question of damages here is a complex one, difficult to determine. The damages sought are substantial, composed of a number of elements, and based in part upon the uncertain value of rare stamps. I am of the opinion that such damages can be determined only after a hearing, at which the defendant should be permitted to introduce evidence on all the issues relating to the amount of damages. Although defendant has requested a jury trial in this case, he has no right to have the matter referred to a jury after default. 6 Moore’s Federal Practice 172 (2d Ed. 1951). Nor does Rule 55(b) (2), F.R. C. P., require that a jury determine the damages. Although it is no doubt within my discretion to order a jury trial on this issue, in view of the defendant’s dilatory tactics I think it is inappropriate to further delay the proceedings by placing the matter on the heavily burdened jury calendar. The plaintiff’s damages should be determined on a hearing before the Court without a jury.
Settle order on notice.