Gary Moawad v. Major Fred Childs and Sgt. Jerry UptonGary Moawad v. Major Fred Childs and Sgt. Jerry Upton
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Garza
Gary Moawad, who alleges that he is Egyptian, appeals from a dismissal with prejudice of a civil rights action which he filed
pro se.
In his suit he had alleged, among other things, that he was harassed by guards, punished without due process, denied a radio or stereo and that his mail was censored. He is an inmate of the Parchman Prison in Mississippi. He sued two of the correctional officers at Parch-man who he charged in the complaint with sundry misdeeds and misbehavior. In his complaint he requested that he be transfer
Without waiting for an answer by the defendants, the magistrate recommended that his complaint be dismissed with prejudice under
This court granted the appellant appeal in forma pauperis and granted his request for appointment of counsel. Appellees first argue to this court that appellant Moawad has waived his right to appeal any issue, other than the finding of the magistrate that he had no right to a transfer because he failed to object to other findings of the magistrate. They rely on Nettles v. Wainwright, 656 F.2d 986 (5th Cir. 1981), rehearing en banc granted.
Even assuming the continued viability of Nettles, supra, which is now under en banc consideration, and U. S. v. Lewis, 621 F.2d 1382 (5th Cir. 1980), cert. denied, 450 U.S. 935, 101 S.Ct. 1400, 67 L.Ed.2d 370 (1981), which was the authority for the Nettles decision, reliance on that case by the appellees is misplaced.
In Nettles, supra, at 987, this court stated that:
We read Lewis to mean that where a party does not object to a recommendation contained in a magistrate’s report within the time allowed, and the recommendation is accepted by the district court, the party will be held to have waived the right to appeal that ruling. This is true even where the ruling is only implicitly reflected in the judgment.
A narrow reading of Nettles and Lewis, supra, leads us to the conclusion that Moawad could not have objected to a recommendation on an issue that he raised where there was no recommendation by the magistrate on that issue. He objected to the issues discussed by the magistrate. In his objections, he did not specifically discuss his other claims, such as his mail censorship claim, his harassment by guards or his classification being changed without due process, because the magistrate did not address these other claims. We find that a litigant, and more precisely a pro se litigant such as the appellant here, cannot be held to have waived an issue raised by his pleadings that is not covered in the magistrate’s findings or recommendations.
A
pro se
complaint such as Moawad’s should not be dismissed unless it appears that the plaintiff can prove no set of facts which would entitle him to relief.
Conley v. Gibson,
355 U.S. 41, 78 S.Ct. 99, 2 L.Ed.2d 80 (1957). In looking at the
pro se
complaint of Moawad and accepting his allegations as true, we must ask ourselves if Moawad has been deprived of a cognizable liberty or property interest.
See Richardson v. Fleming,
651 F.2d 366, 368 (5th Cir. 1981);
see also Haines v. Kerner,
404 U.S. 519, 92 S.Ct. 594, 30 L.Ed.2d 652 (1972). In
Covington v. Cole,
528 F.2d 1365, 1370 (5th Cir. 1976), this court characterized the test as “whether within the universe of theoretically provable facts there exists a set which can support a cause of action under this complaint, indulgently read.” If dismissal of a
pro se
complaint is warranted, it should be without prejudice to allow an inmate to file an amended complaint.
See Mitchell v. Beaubouef,
581 F.2d 412, 416 (5th Cir. 1978),
While the court below might be correct in its holding that the court is without jurisdiction to order prison employees fired or removed, the court below had jurisdiction to look into appellant’s claim that his mail was being censored. Unless proper procedures have been followed, a claim of mail censorship could state a constitutional claim. Guajardo v. Estelle, 580 F.2d 748, 753-763 (5th Cir. 1978), discussing Procunier v. Martinez, 416 U.S. 396, 94 S.Ct. 1800, 40 L.Ed.2d 224 (1974). Obviously, his complaint of mail censorship, of guard harassment and his change of classification without due process require findings of fact to determine the merits of such claims.
Because Moawad’s complaint, liberally construed, stated claims that were not addressed by the court below, we must send his case back to the district court for further proceedings.
REVERSED.