No. 10 | 2d Cir. | Nov 10, 1920
July 9, 1919, the Alien Property Custodian filed this libel against $25,000, par value, of Canada Southern Railway Company bonds and other securities then in the United States Safe Deposit Company of this city, praying the court to enter an order directing the United States marshal to seize and hold the same, and citing all persons having any claim to possession thereof to appear and show cause why the marshal should not deliver them to the libel-ant, the Alien Property Custodian.
The usual monition issued on the same day, the marshal seized the securities July 15, and before the return day of the monition Albert H. Wiggin, Charles H. Sabin, and Walter T. Rosen appeared and claimed the securities as trustees and owners. Subsequently they filed a verified answer, denying the allegations of the libel and setting up several separate independent defenses. Judge Knox granted the government’s motion for judgment on the pleadings in favor of the libelant.
Treating this answer and an affidavit of the attorney for the Alien Property Custodian, which by stipulation is a part of it, as we would in admiralty, we think the judgment directing the marshal to deliver the securities in question to the Alien Property Custodian without prejudice to the claimants, or any of them, or any other person or persons, with respect to any claim or claims they may see fit to file with the Alien Property Custodian pursuant to section 9 of the Trading with the Enemy Act (section 3115J4e), or any suit or suits, action or actions, proceeding or proceedings they or any of them may see fit to institute thereunder or otherwise was right. See our decisions in Garvan v. Bonds, 265 F. 477" date_filed="1920-03-03" court="2d Cir." case_name="Garvan v. $20,000 Bonds">265 Fed. 477.
The judgment is affirmed.