Garner v. FinchGarner v. Finch
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Holt
Lead Opinion
This appeal results from the trial court’s granting appellees’ motion for a new trial following a jury verdict for appellant in the amount of $55,263.00 based upon his claim for personal injuries. Appellant challenges the correctness of that ruling. We affirm.
The trial court is vested with a wide latitude of discretion in acting on a motion for a mistrial or a new trial and will not be reversed on appeal absent a manifest abuse of discretion. General Motors Corp. et al v. Tate, 257 Ark. 347, 516 S.W. 2d 602 (1974); and Dickerson Construction Co. v. Dozier, 266 Ark. 345, 584 S.W. 2d 36 (1979). The showing that a trial judge has abused his discretion must be stronger when a new trial has been granted than when it has been denied, as the beneficiary of the verdict set aside has less basis for a claim of prejudice than does the unsuccessful movant for a new trial. Security Insurance v. Owen, 255 Ark. 526, 501 S.W. 2d 229 (1973).
Appellant was employed by appellee Finch as a farm employee when he accidentally suffered an amputation of the lower portion of his left leg by a rotating auger in a grain cart, which was manufactured by appellees Shaw and House. After a three day trial, the jury retired to deliberate and answer seven interrogatories. The trial judge instructed the jury that only the foreman should sign an interrogatory if it was unanimous; if not, nine or more jurors must agree on the answer to any of the interrogatories and those agreeing must sign. The instructions were then furnished to the jury for its use. The first time the jury returned the foreman advised the court that the jury had reached a verdict; the answers to the first six interrogatories were unanimous; and the seventh interrogatory was signed by nine jurors. However, upon questioning the jury, the court determined that the answers to some were not unanimous. Consequently, the court sent the jury back to further deliberate with instructions again as to how each interrogatory should be signed.
Subsequently, the appellees filed their motions for a new trial, reasserting, inter alia, their motions for mistrial during the trial proceedings. The trial judge, after hearing arguments, granted a new trial, stating that he should have granted the defendants’ motions for a mistrial during the proceedings. In doing so, the court noted that he was not considering, nor had he read, an affidavit of six of the jurors concerning matters which occurred during their deliberations. The court was correct inasmuch as such an affidavit is improper under Arkansas law. See Uniform Rules of Evidence, Rule 606 (b). The court also properly excluded from consideration statements made by a local attorney about reports made to him by some of the jurors. The court then stated:
[I]n the interest of justice and a fair and impartial trial the Court is granting the motion and ordering a new trial in the case so that all parties will have an adequate opportunity to correct any — so it will be beyond the question of suspect as I fear and find this verdict is open to.
The court made a specific finding “that it should have granted certain defense motions for a mistrial during the jury’s deliberations in this matter.”
In the granting or denying of a motion for mistrial, wegive due consideration to the fact the trial judge, having personally observed the entire proceedings, is in a better position than we to evaluate the merits of the motion. When we consider all the circumstances during the trial proceedings, we cannot say that appellant has sufficiently met his burden of demonstrating the trial judge manifestly abused the wide latitude of discretion allowed him by setting aside the jury’s verdict.
Affirmed.
Adkisson, CJ., and Purtle, J., dissent.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting. I respectfully dissent from the majority opinion in this case primarily upon the reasoning we used in the recent case of Scheptmann et al v. Thorn, 272 Ark. 70, 612 S.W. 2d 291 (1981). Both cases are strikingly similar, the chief difference being that in the present case the trial court granted a new trial and in the Scheptmann case a new trial was denied.
In both cases the matter was submitted upon interrogatories and in both cases the central question revolved around the percentage of negligence or total injuries suffered by the plaintiff. In both cases the trial judges answered the inquiry of the jury in a manner which could not possibly be misleading, in my opinion. In Scheptmann et al v. Thorn, supra, we stated:
... But the court spoke only in generalities, so much so that we are wholly unable to see how the jurors could have derived any usable information from the remarks in question.
The cases are strikingly similar in a number of respects not previously mentioned. After the jury had returned and announced their confusion in the present case, the court explained the interrogatories and sent them back to deliberate. While they were out, the opposing party moved for a mistrial. The mistrial was denied. In Scheptmann, supra, after the trial court explained the interrogatories the jury went back to consider them further. During the time they were
In my opinion, the trial judge was closer to the factual situation and the parties at the time he refused to grant the mistrial before the jury had returned with their verdict than he was several weeks later when he set it aside. It is only logical that the matters would have been more prominent in his mind during the trial than they were after outside attorneys had meddled in the matter and jurors had submitted statements. Although the court did not consider these matters, it seems to me it would be nearly impossible not to be aware of the outside activities of another attorney and the improper conduct of obtaining statements from jurors. To affirm this decision will likely encourage others to bring to bear all sorts of pressure on trial judges when the results of a trial are unfavorable to them.
I would reinstate the jury verdict in this case.