Frappier v. MerglerFrappier v. Mergler
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Garcia
This appeal comes before the court for decision following its submission to an advisory committee pursuant to an experimental plan. See Patterson v. Environmental Improvement Div., 105 N.M. 320, 731 P.2d 1364 (Ct.App.1986); Stoll v. Dow, 105 N.M. 316, 731 P.2d 1360 (Ct.App.1986); Boucher v. Foxworth-Galbraith Lumber Co., 105 N.M. 442, 733 P.2d 1325. (Ct.App. 1986). The committee rendered a unanimous decision and the parties were so notified. We acknowledge the aid of attorneys Daniel R. Cron, William R. Federici and Joel V. Burstein, who devoted both time and effort. We express our gratitude for their voluntary service. This court has considered the transcript and briefs in this case, together with the opinion of the advisory committee. We adopt the opinion of the advisory committee in modified form. We affirm in part and reverse in part.
ISSUES
Initially, Frappier raised three issues on appeal. Frappier, however, failed to cite authority in support of her first issue and, thus, we will not address it. See In re Adoption of Doe, 100 N.M. 764, 676 P.2d 1329 (1984). Accordingly, the following issues are properly before us: (1) whether there exist genuine issues of material fact concerning whether defendants had actual notice provided by the New Mexico Tort Claims Act; and (2) whether summary judgment should be reversed as it relates to individual defendants named by plaintiff.
Plaintiff Emiline Frappier (Frappier) filed a complaint for personal injury and monetary damages against John Mergler (Mergler); the Village of Corrales (Village); Thomas Gentry, individually and in his capacity as Mayor of the Village of Corrales (Mayor); Benjie Torres, individually and in his capacity as Chief of Police for the Village of Corrales Police Department (Chief); and the Village of Corrales Police Department (Department).
The lawsuit arose out of an intersection accident occurring on December 29, 1982. Frappier was traveling north on Corrales Road within the Village while Mergler, an on-duty police officer, was responding to an emergency call. At the time of impact, Mergler was proceeding with his emergency equipment, including flashing lights, siren and headlights fully engaged. He was passing in northbound traffic by driving in the southbound lane. Frappier was at the intersection, and while making a left-hand turn from her northbound lane, the vehicles collided.
The Bernalillo County Sheriffs Department responded to the accident, conducted an investigation and issued a police report. The narrative section of the report recited:
Vehicle # 1 [police car] was responding to call, emergency lights, siren operating, overtook vehicle # 2 [Frappier vehicle] on left side, vehicle # 2 driver did not hear siren, or see lights behind her, turned left into path of vehicle # 1[.] Vehicles collided. Vehicle # 1 also struck telephone pole and fence posts.
The police report indicated that neither Frappier nor Mergler complained of any injuries at the scene. The report did indicate, however, that each of the vehicles had sustained damage in excess of $100. Within minutes of the accident, the Chief arrived at the scene and observed that each vehicle had sustained heavy damage. The Mayor, who is a member of the fire department’s rescue unit, also appeared at the accident scene.
Within ten days of the accident, the Village filed a claim with its own insurer to recover for damages sustained by the police vehicle. The Mayor personally handled the details of the claim and made personal contact with the claims adjustor from the Village’s insurance company. The Village’s insurer received two claims as a result of the accident. One was from its own insured, the Village, and a second was submitted by a utility company for damage to a utility pole. That claim was not paid. Rather, the adjustor testified that “we had referred them [utility] to the responsible party, Mr. Frappier, Mr. or Mrs. Frappier.” The insurance company covered the damages sustained by the Village and ultimately closed its file on this matter.
Approximately two years after the accident, Frappier filed a lawsuit seeking monetary damages for personal injuries she sustained as a result of the accident. Prior to the filing of the suit, Frappier gave no written notice to the Village indicating that the governmental entity was at fault or that it would be subject to a claim or lawsuit. Moreover, Frappier had not verbally communicated with any official or employee of the Village indicating that she might pursue a claim against the Village as a consequence of the accident in question, or that she considered the accident to be the fault of any person or governmental entity that she joined as a defendant in the action.
Defendants filed a motion for summary judgment on the grounds that plaintiff had failed to demonstrate compliance with mandatory notice provisions pursuant to
Issue I
This issue presents the question of whether the Village, through its appropriate officials, was given timely and sufficient “actual notice” of plaintiff’s claim for damages under the Tort Claims Act (TCA),
In City of Las Cruces v. Garcia, 102 N.M. 25, 690 P.2d 1019 (1984), plaintiff was involved in a car accident. A police report was filed, a copy of which was routinely sent to the city traffic department. Subsequently, plaintiff filed suit against the driver of the other vehicle, and the State of New Mexico: (State) and the City of Las Cruces (City) for negligent maintenance of the intersection where the accident occurred. Both the State and the City moved for summary judgment, arguing that they received no notice, written or “actual,” as required under the TCA. Both motions were granted.
This court affirmed the granting of summary judgment to the State, but reversed as to the City. In reversing, we noted that the city traffic department routinely receives copies of all City accident reports and since the City was one of the alleged responsible parties in the accident, an issue of material.fact existed as to whether the city traffic department’s receipt of a copy of the accident report constituted “actual notice” under the TCA.
On certiorari, the supreme court noted that the purpose behind
Subsequently, in Smith, this court determined that
Here, the police report did not indicate that Mergler was at fault, nor did the report indicate that Frappier had complained of any physical injuries as a consequence of the collision. To the contrary, both the police report and other information the governmental entities had indicated that Frappier was the responsible party. In fact, the police report specifically stated that Frappier “did not hear siren, or see lights behind her, [and] turned left into path of [police car] * * *.” The only indication on the report of any loss suffered by Frappier was the notation that her automobile had sustained damage in excess of $100. While there is no dispute that the Village had actual notice of the accident, that is insufficient to vest the Village with the knowledge that it or any of its employees may be subject to a lawsuit or of the likelihood of litigation as a result of that accident. The facts contained in the police report, alone, are not even sufficient to put the Village or the Department on notice that Frappier considered the accident to be the fault of any of the defendants.
The question of whether the knowledge of Mergler, the Chief and the Mayor constituted actual knowledge requies the same conclusion. There exists no indication from the record that Mergler, the Chief, the Mayor or anyone else present at the scene of the accident was apprised at that time, or at any time within the statutory period, that Frappier considered the accident to be the fault of any of the defendants or that the filing of a lawsuit by Frappier was likely. Similarly, no such information was provided by Frappier to the Village, the Department, or any of the agents or employees of the Village or Department during the ninety-day period that ensued after the accident. As a result, we hold, consistent with City of Las Cruces v. Garcia, that actual notice was not provided to the Village or the Department as required under
Issue II
Frappier sued the Chief and the Mayor both individually and in their respective capacities as employees of the Village. Frappier contends that notice under
CONCLUSION
The trial court’s granting of summary judgment in favor of the Village and Department is affirmed; the trial court’s granting of summary judgment against all other defendants is reversed. We remand this matter to the trial court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DONNELLY, C.J., and MINZNER, J., concur.