Fitzpatrick's Inc. v. Commissioner of Motor VehiclesFitzpatrick's Inc. v. Commissioner of Motor Vehicles
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Shapiro
Lead Opinion
Following a hearing, the defendant commissioner of motor vehicles concluded that the plaintiff had violated
There was evidence before the commissioner from which he could find the following facts pertinent to this appeal: On January 7,1971, William Pidlipehak purchased a 1970 Plymouth Fury III from the plaintiff. The vehicle was previously owned by Avis Rent A Car System, Inc., hereinafter Avis. The purchase order between Pidlipehak and the plaintiff described the vehicle as an “Exc Demo.” The vehicle was represented to the buyer as an “executive demonstrator” and not as a leasing company vehicle. From these facts the commissioner concluded that the plaintiff violated the provisions of
Whether Pidlipchak was aware that he was purchasing a used car from the plaintiff has a bearing in this appeal only if the trial court is found to have committed error in concluding that there was no sufficient basis in the record for the commissioner’s finding that the plaintiff violated
Since
It is significant to note that in the 1973 session of the General Assembly
In
*421There is no error.
In this opinion House, C. J., Loiselee and Bogdanski, Js., concurred.
Notes
Dissenting Opinion
(dissenting). I cannot agree with the opinion of the majority. The difference between prior ownership and use by a motor vehicle rental service and prior ownership and use by a sales executive demonstrating a new model vehicle is too vast to require elaboration or comment. The “mode or state of being,” “state or situation” or any other definition of “condition” when applied to a used motor vehicle is so inextricably dependent upon its prior use that‘it is, in my opinion, wholly unrealistic to hold that misrepresentation as to prior ownership and use should not be construed to mean misrepresentation as to condition, even under the strict construction required of a statute penal in nature.
The 1973 amendment of
The representations in this case with respect to prior ownership were a substantial factor in the sale of the vehicle and a material fact in determining its value. The plaintiff had ample reason to know that such representations were not true. From the foregoing, the commissioner concluded that the plaintiff violated the provisions of
I would find error, set aside the judgment and remand the ease with direction to render judgment dismissing the appeal.