History
  • No items yet
midpage
First Nat. Bank of Caddo v. Monnig Dry Goods Co.
280 S.W. 174
Tex. Comm'n App.
1926
Check Treatment
HARVEY, P. J.

On November 8, 1924, this cause, with plaintiff in error, First National Bank of Caddo, Tex., as appellant, and defendant in error Monnig Dry Goods Company, as appellee, was pending on appeal in the Court of Civil Appeals for the Second Supreme Judicial District. On said-date said Court of 'Civil Appeals entered an order striking said cause from the docket of said court on the ground that the record therein did not disclose that notice of appeal from the judgment of the trial court had been given by appellant. On November 21, 1924, the appellant, First National Bank of Caddo, Tex., filed in said court its motion to have said cause reinstated on the docket of said court, alleging, in substance, that such notice of appeal had in fact been duly given and was duly noted on the docket of the trial court by the trial court. In support of its said motion, the said bank submitted certified copy of the entries on the docket of the trial court, which show that notice of appeal was duly given by plaintiff in error. On December 15, 1924, said Court of Civil Appeals overruled said motion to reinstate, and the order of court overruling such motion is before us for review.

We are of opinion that the Court of Civil Appeals erred in overruling said motion to reinstate said cause on its docket. Revised Statutes of 1925, art. 1822; Western Union Tel. Co. v. O’Keefe, 28 S. W. 945, 87 Tex. 423; Luse v. Parmer (Tex. Civ. App.) 221 S. W. 1031.

We therefore recommend that the order of the ‘Court of Civil Appeals, overruling such motion to reinstate, be reversed, and that said court be directed to reinstate this cause, and, when the cause has been so reinstated, that the plaintiff in error be given the opportunity to show, in such manner as such court may direct under the law, the fact that notice of appeal was given as alleged by plaintiff in error in its motion to reinstate. We further recommend that the record herein be transmitted to the Court of Civil Appeals.

CURETON, C. J.

Judgment- of the Court of Civil Appeals reversed, and cause remanded to the Court of Civil Appeals, as recommended by the Commission of Appeals.

Case Details

Case Name: First Nat. Bank of Caddo v. Monnig Dry Goods Co.
Court Name: Texas Commission of Appeals
Date Published: Feb 10, 1926
Citation: 280 S.W. 174
Docket Number: No. 733-4325
Court Abbreviation: Tex. Comm'n App.
AI-generated responses must be verified and are not legal advice.