First Methodist Episcopal Church v. SwenyFirst Methodist Episcopal Church v. Sweny
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Given
The following facts appear without controversy, and will be sufficient to a correct understanding of the questions presented: On and before February 27, 1884, the members and friends of the plaintiff church contemplated the erection of a new church building, and, as the church then owned ground on the corner of Fifth and Division streets, it was assumed and expected by many of the congregation that the new building would be erected thereon. On February 27, 1884, in pursuance of an announcement made from the pulpit, the ladies of the chuch held a meeting, and organized the Church Furnishing Society, composed almost exclusively of lady members of the church, of which society the defendant was elected treasurer. The purpose of the society, as declared in its constitution *630and by-laws, was, “to procure funds for the furnishing of the new church on its completion.” The place of meeting was fixed to be at the First Methodist Episcopal church, and the pastor and people of that church co-operated with the society in its work. During the year following its organization the society held stated meetings at the church, and gave entertainments there and elsewhere to iaise money for the purpose expressed, which meetings and entertainments were previously announced from the plaintiff’s pulpit. The amount in question was accumulated by the payment of stated dues by the members of the society, by admission fees to the entertainments, and voluntary contributions. It appears that it was within the power of the quarterly conference to decide upon the location of the new church, and that the first action taken by the conference was after the organization, to-wit March 31, 1884, at which meeting a resolution as follows was offered: “Resolved, that the trustees and building committee be authorized and directed to build a new Methodist Episcopal church on the southwest corner of Fifth and Division streets, on the lots now owned by the church.” Final action was not had upon this resolution until the meeting held April 7, 1884, when the resolution was amended by adding the words, “or the northwest corner of Fifth and Division,” and by prefixing the words, “that, when we build, it be one of the locations owned by the church.” This resolution, as ■ thus amended, was adopted by the conference. At a meeting held April 28, following, action was taken for the raising of funds with which to erect the new church. No further action with respect to the location was taken by the conference until May 31, 1886, when the subject of location was opened up, and continued to be a matter of dispute at several meetings of the conference up to February 6, 1888, when the southeast corner of Washington and Fifth streets was adopted as the location. *631The Church Furnishing Society continued to prosecute its work for about one year after its organization, and accumulated six hundred and thirty-two dollars and two cents, the money now in the hands of the defendant. Notwithstanding the action of the conference of April 7, 1884, locating the new church on the corner of Fifth and Division streets, the subject of location continued to be ■ discussed, many of the church members favoring a different location. Owing to this contention, and the delay in raising funds and prosecuting the work on the new church, the society ceased its efforts. Before the commencement of this action, several persons who had contributed to the fund in question told the defendant that, if the church was not located on the corner of Fifth and Division streets, they wanted their money refunded, and several other members of the society authorized her, in writing; to pay the money contributed by them to the Grace Methodist Episcopal church, of Burlington, because of the new church of the plaintiff not having been located on the corner of Fifth and Division streets.
I. The defendant was permitted to testify, over the plaintiffs’s objection, her understanding that it had
Presiding Elder Cowles was permitted to testify, over the plaintiff’s objection, that it was generally understood by members of the conference and others, that the purchase of the additional lot fixed the location of the new church. We think this evidence was also admissible as tending to show whether the funds in question were contributed upon the condition claimed.
II. The appellant’s further contention is that there is no evidence tending to show that the amount in ques-
III. It is contended that the Church Furnishing Society was a mere auxiliary, and subject to the control
IV. The appellant contends that the defense that the money was contributed upon the condition claimed
The judgment of the district court is aeeibmed.