midpage

Fenner v. Buffalo and State Line Railroad CompanyFenner v. Buffalo and State Line Railroad Company

New York Court of Appeals
May 6, 1871
Reporters:
,
Before:
Earl

*1 Fenner v. Buffalo Line R. R. and-State Statement of case.

tained that of the bales did any not come to the up require- ments of the these contract, have they rejected returned to the would plaintiffs, be retaining, obliged all to, that answered to the contract.

I am therefore of the opionion judgment be affirmed with costs.

All concur for affirmance. affirmed, with

Judgment costs. Mandana D. Fenner, v. The Buffalo Respondent,

State Line Railroad Company, Appellant. duty of common by railroad, carriers as to the place of destination, subject is following to the consignee rules: If the is present upon arrival, he must take them delay. without unreasonable present, If he is not but lives at or in vicinity the immediate notify the carrier must arrival, him of their and he then has a reasonable time within which to remove them. If he absent, unknown, found, or cannot be then the carrier can them in its freight-house, and, consignee if the does not call for them in reasonable time, liability as a common consignee carrier ceases. If the has a not, reasonable to remove them and does he cannot hold the as an insurer. carrier When, goods, and, has notice of the arrival of his without unwillingness part any to deliver on the agrees refusal latter, convenience, for their mutual that the with left over- ceased, night freight-house, as a common carrier has destroyed during night, company goods being fire as an insurer. cannot ‍​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌​​‌‌‌​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌​‌‌​​​‌‌​​‌​‌​​‌‌​​​‍be held specified point, shipped by railroad to a whence the goods are owner When destination, company the railroad them to their final intends remove applicable are carrier and the rules those is not an intermediate of destination. govern at respondent, January 14th; appellant and submitted for the (Argued for the May 6, 1871.) decided fur- household the 24th of certain

On or about May, delivered to the defend- niture, plaintiff, belonging FT. Fenner, Dunkirk, and directed to F. P. ant, marked its railroad to said furniture over defendant carried —Hand Y. Yol. 64’ Line v. Buffalo R. Co. *2 of case.

Statement of transportar furniture was fact course Dunkirk. H. Y., Sinelairville, County, Chautauqua tion to known but this fact was Dunkirk, distance short at the furniture the arrival of until after the defendant Dunkirk. afternoon Dunkirk arrived at

The furniture during ain suitable freight- and was unloaded 24th, May same the latter part the defendant. house of During in the business a teamster, Alfred afternoon, Austin, engaged Sinelair- Dunkirk and team-between carrying goods the fur- obtain authorized plaintiff who was ville, at the defendant at the office of her, niture for called furniture, and asked for team, Dunkirk with thereon arrived, it had freight paid ascertained having He then went to employe therefor. receipt signed to attend it was whose business defendant, him and found of the furniture, engaged delivery six It was then to other nearly parties. was ordinarily the hour freight-house o’clock, in Dunkirk the and Austin occasion closed; having then and arranged next for other goods, morning convenience, mutual and the for him employe, between there- should call wait for but furniture, that he should not for the next morning. ;was and the burned, night freight-house

During fault consumed, without any neg- furniture was wholly the defendant. ligence this action recover thereafter commenced

The plaintiff at issue same furniture, put value of the referee, trial, before and referred. Hpon and decided that and the referee held facts appeared, foregoing furniture as a common car- was liable the defendant for the value thereof. rier, plaintiff judgment gave the General the defendant appealed From this judgment of affirmance and from district, the seventh Term of judgment there to court. 103. 46 Barbour,

The case below reported, R. and State R. Co. BDEBALO Fenner V. per Court, Opinion of the v. cited Thomas Sherman S. Rogers, appellant, Co. & Plains Metc., Norway Bos. Prov. R. Co. (16 477); v. N. Y. & v. & Maine R. McCarty Bost. (1 Gray, 275); Ce R. Co. v. Alexan St., 247); R. Penn. nt. E. Co. (30 Ill. R. I. R. Porter v. & Co. Ill., (id., der 23); Chicago 407); (20 v. Mich. Davis v. Sance (id., Richards S. R. Co. 404); (id., R. Cin. Ind., Bausemer v. Tol. & W. Co. (25 434); 412;) v. Y. C. id., & Chic. R. Co. v. McCool Drury (26 140); B. R. & N. Y. (13 Gray, 487); Northrop Sy., *3 Trans. McMillan v. M. S. & N. I. R. Co. (2 App., 183); Mich., 79, Co. (16 123).

Cox & Avery, cited on respondent, Carr., Angell §§ and 2 281, 282, 287, 296, cited; cases Kent Com., 604, 6th Merritt v. Earle N. Miller ed.; (29 v. Steam Y., 117); Nav. Co. N. Y., Gould v. (10 N. 431); Chapin (20 266); La Due v. (25 Y., 364). Griffith

Earl, C. It is well in settled an State, interme diate one carrier, who receives over transported his and route, thence other carriers to their of desti by remains nation, liable as a common carrier until ‍​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌​​‌‌‌​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌​‌‌​​​‌‌​​‌​‌​​‌‌​​​‍he generally ‘ has delivered the to the next carrier. v. (Miller Steam Co., N. Navigation Y., 431; Gould v. Chapin, N. Y., 266; Ladue v. 25 N. Griffith, McDonald Y., 364; Western v. Railroad 34 N. Y., It Corporation, 497.) wise, deemed of the common law policy principles should be so that the expounded of one applied, car rier should until continue that of the next carrier commenced. “ in Chief Gould v. Chapin, Mo owner Judge says: Johnson, can be have an each supposed agent superintend trans of his shipment course of line of goods, trans long if portation; of each carrier is not responsibility until continued in fact to the next or at least carrier, until the first carrier, some act his by clearly indicating pur terminates his relation as shall pose, we carrier, greatly diminish the of convenience those whose security pro y. Btjeealo

508 . R. R. Court, per Opinion of the no others, is abandoned to with safeguards perty necessarily rules of afford.” In McDonald save those which the law The Western Railroad Judge speaking Corporation, Smith, “ The of over successive lines, says: carriage he them to the owner delivers loses sight whereabouts first and has no means of learning till he or the of their arrival informed At of transfer each successive destination. point from one carrier to are liable to be another, they accumulation warehouses, be delayed by perhaps $ie fire or causes, theft, or other loss exposed freight fault on the or his without of the carrier Super- part agents. loss collision, to these are the added risks, dangers quite as imminent while the are thus stored at some point are transit. As unknown the owner as while actual circumstances rule, under such general storing and the held to be mere accessory transportation, makes should be under the rule which protection trans the carrier the time the owner liable insurer, *4 the till are delivered fers their to first carrier possession they to him-at the end of the I have extracted much route.” into view the of these learned to from opinions bring judges, based, the to which decisions grounds upon and not carriers, that intermediate show to they only apply final to who to their destination. carriers transport laid down these That the decisions be 4n principles in the in the case of was held Court limited, Appeals, in Y. R. R. decided Co., B. and N. Syracuse, Northrop in 183. In that case the 2 Trans. 1867, reported App., a certain to for the transport plaintiffs quan defendant agreed wheat in the to county from Onondaga, Tully, tity and did The wheat Forks, so same. transport Chenango marked, in and was directed to was ¡fiaintiffs, bags, resided miles from fifteen Forks, although they Chenango at Chester where intended to there, carry village, Eo receive wheat. one present plaintiffs being to it there Forks, on its arrival at wheat, deposited Chenango Line R. R. and State v. IS1?!.] Court, per Earl, Opinion of the at four o’clock defendant, ill the freight-house afternoon on 1859. The afternoon, plaintiffs, August sent had been that the wheat notice next received day, Forks, following night to Tully Chenango the 10th of and on fire; August wheat consumed It was held and demanded the wheat. sent for plaintiffs for carrier, that the was not liable as common defendant rule was The that the not recover. wheat and plaintiffs laid in that a railroad carrier safely down, case, that, no destination, and, finding their to transports goods one there to notice can receive or to whom given them their them in its arrival, keeps places freight-house, resonable time, ready uninjured ceases and that it to be liable as a common carrier; for the carrier of the arrival of necessary notice give at, reside did ‍​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌​​‌‌‌​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌​‌‌​​​‌‌​​‌​‌​​‌‌​​​‍not who, case, consignee, inor the immediate of, vicinity

were consigned.

The courts below defeated the defendant in this case, upon the erroneous it was assumption intermediate within the of the cases first above meaning cited, and,’ hence, that this case was controlled laid down those principles cases. The contract of an intermediate carrier is to carry to the end of and their route, deliver them the next carrier for further transportation. contract of the final carrier is to transport of desti nation, and there deliver them to the owner; such was the contract this case. Here the were con to F. P. signed Fenner, Dunkirk, and defendant undertook to *5 them to carry Dunkirk, and/there deliver them to the con and it had signee, no as to their duty further trans whatever It was the portation. of the duty or her plaintiff, consignee, to take the at and goods Dunkirk, see or to, for, their arrange ” further The transportation. in this defendant, was case, no | more an intermediate carrier than the defendant in the f case v. Northrop Syracuse, and New Binghamton York Railroad The rule to Company. be to this applied case,then, R, and

Opinion Court, per of the the is one that is to carriers who applicable to goods carry final their destination. This rule is not deter very definitely In mined this State. and some of the other Massachusetts, States, it is the settled that moment railroad carrier carries to their final destination, to contract, its and goods according them in its its lia-’ deposits freight-house, ready as carrier and it ceases, remains liable as ware bility simply houseman. But this rule has not State, been this adopted and should not It be. is not or always, practicable generally, to be on the arrival of the consignee present, to goods, is receive it as them; that the carrier just important should continue liable, as an insurer of the for a goods, reasonable time after their until arrival, the can consignee an have to take as it should charge liable the transit during to place of destination. all

At were carried early land in day, upon it was carrier to deliver wagons, generally duty ator his consignee of resi- personally, or This was dence business. so because carrier could go with his make the But car- anywhere wagons delivery. as water, riers confined upon their means of to the water, were bound to deliver their transportation only the wharf or and if the was upon pier; consignee pre- it at was his once to sent, take of the If duty charge goods. lived he -was but present, destination, it of the carrier to him notice of arrival duty give If of the he absent, dead, goods. found, not be the earner in a discharged duty by depositing warehouse, order It seems subject consignee. me same rules, for the same rea- substantially should be sons, railroad carrier. It is applied obliged as water carrier is at wharf, stop depot, on arrival unless present them from is the cars, must, take well known them in custom, uniform its From the freight-house. I State, drift decisions think we infer fairly may *6 y. 511 and Leste R. Buffalo R. Femes Court, per Opinion rules as to the at their following a If railroad carrier: of destination by pre consignee arrival without he must take them sent upon goods, If he is not lives unreasonable delay. present,but must immediate carrier vicinity him the then a rea arrival and he has goods, notify and time ‍​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌​​‌‌‌​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌​‌‌​​​‌‌​​‌​‌​​‌‌​​​‍to take remove them. If he is absent, sonable or cannot be then the unknown, found, carrier can place in its after and, them reasona freight-house, keeping if the does not call for its time, ble liability consignee as a common carrier ceases. after the arrival If, of the goods, reasonable to remove them, ‘has and he cannot hold the not, carrier as insurer. The does carrier’s and I will be believe applied limited, found consonant with and conveni public policy, sufficiently ent and Powell v. (See Wend., 591; 26 practicable. Myers, Fisk v. Newton, Denio., 45; Jones v. The and Norwich Trans. Co., Barb., 193; New York Roth v. and 34 N. Co., State Line R. 548; Syracuse Northrop Y. R. R. Co., B. supra.) I think the defendant in this law,

Within these rules was not for the loss of the case liable question. teamster, Austin, was He had notice of agent.’ plaintiff’s the arrival of goods, paid freight gave Just at that defendant time the railroad them. receipt in’ other But there delivering freight. employe engaged to deliver so far and, no refusal these goods, appears, to deliver and I think are them; we bound no unwillingness if Austin had demanded the would infer, goods, they to him. It was and as late, delivered have been getting return the next for his con Austin intended to day, again I to remain. venience, permitted say It matters that it was also for the con convenience. their mutual the railroad or for con venience of employe, Austin have had is sufficient that It venience. under an were left that they arrangement goods, assented, to which he as much for his he participated, *7 R. R. v. Opinion Court, per Leonard, of the Com. convenience as convenience the of other Sup party. the had been leave a the pose arrangement goods aor week, for their mutual the month, convenience, would railroad have as a remained liable common ? carrier company there is a Here, then, case where the ha consignee’s agent d of arrival notice the of the had an goods r to remove he them in the them, left defendant’s freight- house, because was more convenient him for to call ” them the next Under a such state of facts, morning. the were left in the for the mutual goods freight-house accommodation and the convenience of both parties, law an one impose upon party responsibility I insurer? think and that neither nor not, justice public that, in requires facts policy case, upon existing defendant should be held liable aas carrier. common

I am in therefore favor of reversing judgments a new costs to abide the event. trial, granting The Leonard, C. referee held this case to be within decided Ladue v. Y. principle R., N. (25 364). Griffith The General Term held that it was within decision’ In cases, Goold each Chapin (20 of those 259). were at intermediate the goods destroyed In and of one case the were shipment delivery. in a barge carrier, for floating belonging transhipment another In line. other case in storehouse of the car rier, for same It was held that purpose. intermediate carriers were in transported by possession each intermediate until carrier, to the next one on delivery route, on, and so one carrier to until another, reached the final destination. The Court of an refused consider such intermediate who carrier, Appeals in his own storehouse had stored floating barge termination route such waiting receive as less next carrier any subject while the attached to carrier actual than under insurer, carrier regarded transportation. Like Feketeb v. Buffalo akd State R. R. ‍​‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌‌‌​‌‌‌​‌‌‌‌​​​​​‌‌‌​​​​‌​​‌‌‌​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌​‌‌‌‌​‌​​​‌‌​‌‌‌‌‌​​​‌​‌‌​​​‌‌​​‌​‌​​‌‌​​​‍Co. Opinion Com‘t, per Leonard, such not as circumstances, warehouseman, relieved of a degree liability.

In the were marked for present case, Dunkirk, the defendant them point safely conveyed *8 and there them in its storehouse. The placed plaintiff wished the carried further another whom she by agent, had authorized to demand receive the from the defendant at Dunkirk. The defendant not an interme- diate carrier. The had been carried to the destination where the had defendant been deliver requested must be inferred from marks on the packages.

In case differs my opinion, present wholly cases referred to the referee and the G-eneral Term. defendant had its contract. It was performed ready deliver. It had ceased to abe was then keeping in safe till the chose to take them. custody plaintiff It would be an unreasonable to attach or continue - that of common carriers, after the had been safely had been brought destination, removed from the defendant’s in a cars, depot warehouse for when called for the owner or If the agent. were to be carried it was under a further, new with contract, which the defendant had no connection. The judgment should be reversed and a trial new ordered, with costs to abide the event.

All concur for reversal, concur reasoning Eabl, C. reversed and new trial costs to abide the

Judgment granted, event.

Hakd—Yol. Y.

Case Details

Case Name: Fenner v. . Buffalo and State Line R.R. Co.
Court Name: New York Court of Appeals
Date Published: May 6, 1871
Citations: 44 N.Y. 505; 1871 N.Y. LEXIS 69
Court Abbreviation: N.Y.
Log In