Farris v. . R. R.Farris v. . R. R.
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Manning
The evidence offered shows the following facts: Stanly Farris was killed on 29 May, 1907, at about 12 o‘clock of the day, by being run over by four gondola cars moving on a track in the yard of (486) the defendant, Southern Railway Company, at Asheville. The intestate was an employee of the defendant company and had been in its service for about eight months prior to his death. The defendant company was doing on its yards at Asheville a large amount of work, rearranging its tracks, widening its yard, increasing the number of tracks and building a stock pen. The intestate had been constantly and regularly at work for defendant company, engaged in doing different jobs, as a water boy, carrying water for the other employes, etc., and for a week prior to his death had been assisting in building the stock pens. The stock pens were on the south side of the yards; the intestate lived on the north side of the yards. On the south side the embankment was about 3 or 3 1/2 feet high; on the north side, about 25 feet, except at a depression. The employees of the defendant company, numbering from 100 to 150, some of whom worked on the yards, others elsewhere, together with other laborers working for a tannery on the south of defendant company‘s yard, crossed the yards to and from the depression in the embankment on the north side to and from the south side, from two to three times daily. A whistle, sounded at the roundhouse of the defendant company, gave the signal for its employees to stop at the noon hour for dinner. The place, above described, where the large number of employees crossed the yards, was about three-fourths of a mile to a
From the judgment entered on the verdict the defendants appealed to this Court. After stating the case: The question first presented for our consideration is the negligence of the defendants. If the evidence does not prove or tend to prove a breach of duty by the defendants towards the plaintiff‘s intestate, and that such breach of duty resulted proximately in the injury complained of, then it must follow that the motion to nonsuit ought to have been allowed for failure of proof on the first issue.
In Wilson v. R. R., 142 N.C. 333, Mr. Justice Brown, speaking for this Court, said: “The attempt to make a running switch across a much-frequented street is not only a negligent but a most dangerous and unwarranted operation, and has been so held by a number of courts. Bradley v. R. R., 126 N.C. 735; Brown v. R. R., 32 N.Y. 597; Falener v. R. R., 68 Miss. 355; R. R. v. Summers, 68 Miss. 566; French v. R. R., 116 Mass. 537; R. R. v. Garvey, 58 Ill. 83; R. R. v. Baches, 55 Ill. 379.
In the present case the intestate of plaintiff occupied toward the
We proceed next to the consideration of the motion to nonsuit, as it applies to the second issue — the contributory negligence of the plaintiff‘s intestate. Upon this issue his Honor charged the jury: “It is the duty of persons going on the track of a railroad company to stop and look and listen for any train that may be moving or lying on the track of such company and on its yards, where there are several tracks used for shifting cars, to be continually alert and on the lookout for a moving train or cars; and if a person fails in this duty, and in consequence of such failure is injured by moving cars, the person would be guilty of contributory negligence.” While the burden of this issue rested on the defendants, the burden of duty rested upon the intestate. The law does not presume contributory negligence; it must be alleged and proven;
It must not be overlooked, in reaching a conclusion in this case, that the act which occasioned plaintiff‘s intestate to be killed was immediately caused by the rapidly moving engine, passing within two feet of him, at a time and place where defendants admit that they knew the intestate would be crossing, and at a time and place where the uncontradicted evidence shows that between 100 and 150 employees of defendant company and others were accustomed to cross the tracks of the yard. We are therefore of the opinion that the motion to nonsuit, upon the evidence bearing on the second issue, ought not to have been allowed, and that his Honor did not err in submitting this issue to the jury.
The defendants objected to his Honor‘s submitting the third issue — that issue presenting the “last clear chance.” While this issue has become immaterial, in view of the finding of the jury on the first and second issues, we think it was proper for his Honor to have submitted it. If the jury had found with defendants on the second issue, having found the first issue with plaintiff, the ultimate liability of defendants would have been determined by their finding on the third issue. In the presence of the concurring negligence of a plaintiff and a defendant, it is a generally accepted doctrine, and well settled in this State, that the ultimate liability must depend upon whether the defendant could at the time have avoided the injury by the exercise of reasonable care, under the attendant circumstances. Ray v. R. R., 141 N.C. 84; Reid v. R. R., 140 N.C. 146; Lassiter v. R. R., 133 N.C. 244; Arrowood v. R. R., 126 N.C. 629; Pickett v. R. R., 117 N.C. 616.
During the trial, the plaintiff, over defendant‘s objection, was permitted to offer evidence tending to show that the defendant company could have provided a safe way of crossing by building at small
No error.
Cited: Snipes v. Mfg. Co., 152 N.C. 45; House v. R. R., ibid., 399; Heilig v. R. R., ibid., 471; Edge v. R. R., 153 N.C. 215; Wolfe v. R. R., 154 N.C. 576; Boney v. R. R., 155 N.C. 108; Zachary v. R. R., 156 N.C. 503; Johnson v. R. R., 163 N.C. 445, 447; Talley v. R. R., ibid., 571, 579; Kenney v. R. R., 165 N.C. 103; Shepard v. R. R., 166 N.C. 545; Gray v. R. R., 167 N.C. 437; Buchanan v. Lumber Co., 168 N.C. 47; Penninger v. R. R., 170 N.C. 475; Lutterloh v. R. R., 172 N.C. 118; McManus v. R. R., 174 N.C. 737.