Everchanged, Inc. v. First Nationwide Mortgage Corp. (In Re Everchanged, Inc.)Everchanged, Inc. v. First Nationwide Mortgage Corp. (In Re Everchanged, Inc.)
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Davis
ORDER ON MOTION TO SET ASIDE FORECLOSURE AND TO IMPOSE SANCTIONS
LAMAR W. DAVIS, Jr., Bankruptcy Judge.On the day following the filing of this Chapter 11 petition Respondent, First Nationwide Mortgage Corporation (“FNMC”), having been provided with prior notice of the pendency of Debtor’s case, conducted a nonjudicial foreclosure of certain real estate located in Chatham County, Georgia, after announcing that the sale would be subject to prior approval of this Court. Debtor contends that the FNMC’s action in conducting the sale constitutes a willful violation of the automatic stay and seeks an order setting aside the foreclosure, awarding attorney’s fees and damages. FNMC contends that its actions did not violate the automatic stay, that the Motion should be dismissed and that the creditor’s action in conducting the sale should be approved insofar as to permit it to convey the property to the successful bidder.
FINDINGS OF FACT
Debtor acquired title to the subject real estate in 1996 and assumed the obligation to repay a mortgage in favor of FNMC’s predecessor. Debtor’s president and sole share
Over a period of many months, Debtor came to be in arrears in repayment of its monthly obligations to the extent of approximately $93,000.00. After FNMC advised that it intended to foreclose, an agreement was reached between the parties whereby the Debtor remitted the sum of $35,000.00 in cash and promised to pay FNMC the balance of $58,000.00 by October 22,1998, in order to cure the arrearages (Ex. D-6). The source of the $35,000.00 remitted by Debtor was proceeds of a transaction between the Debtor and Beacon Group L.L.C. (“Beacon”). As a result of the transaction Beacon transferred $35,000.00 to the Debtor in exchange for a warranty deed conveying all of the Debtor’s right, title and interest in the subject property to Beacon. (FNMC Response, Ex. A). The Debtor subsequently defaulted in making the October lump sum payment of $58,-000.00. FNMC, as a result of the default, proceeded with a previously scheduled foreclosure sale.
At the time of the foreclosure, therefore, record title to the property was vested in Beacon Group, L.L.C., and not in the Debtor. The Debtor alleges that it had a “potential” property interest in the subject real estate because of an unrecorded agreement whereby the Debtor could tender funds in an undetermined amount to Beacon, in exchange for which Beacon would reconvey title to the real estate. No written agreement was introduced in Court, however, and no such agreement appears of record in the Office of the Clerk of Superior of Chatham County, Georgia. Accordingly, for the purposes of this Motion it is clear that, at the time of filing, the Debtor’s estate did not include the subject real estate, as a matter of record title.
In seeking to set aside the foreclosure sale, however, Debtor contends that the provisions of
FNMC further contends that while its action in conducting a foreclosure
on estate property
would be stayed by the provisions of
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The automatic stay of
“Property of the estate” is defined in
An option to purchase land is not an interest in property under Georgia law.
Martin v. Schindley,
264 Ga. 142, 143, 442 S.E.2d 239, 241 (1994). An option only becomes a contract “between the parties binding from the date of its execution when the option is exercised according to its terms . . . An option to purchase land does not, before acceptance, vest in the holder of the option any interest,
legal or equitable,
in the land which is the subject of the action.”
Id.
(emphasis supplied). Whatever the alleged agreement between the parties, therefore, state law clearly does not afford a property interest to Debtor in this ease. Since the alleged option to repurchase does not fall within the definition of “property of the estate” under
Debtor alternatively contends that the foreclosure violated
If we were to accept this interest as sufficient to invoke in [Debtor’s] favor the automatic stay provision of11 U.S.C. § 362(a) , we would be cutting off foreclosure rights of secured creditors in any property standing as security for a debt that happened to be guaranteed by a bankrupt. This cannot have been an intended function of the automatic stay provision, any more than it was intended to prevent a secured creditor from collecting from or foreclosing on the property of a bankruptcy debtor’s guarantors or codebtors.
Geris,
973 F.2d at 321. In fact, Debtor’s reading of
Debtor’s argument highlights the important distinction between a foreclosure, which is
in rem,
and an attempt by a creditor to enforce a deficiency judgment against the obligated Debtor, which is
in personam. In rem
foreclosure on non-estate property does not violate the automatic stay because
Judicial confirmation does not always follow a foreclosure and did not in this case. A secured creditor must, if the foreclosure property is sold for less than the secured debt, obtain a judicial confirmation of the sale as a condition precedent to obtaining a deficiency judgment.
ORDER
In consideration of the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, IT IS THE ORDER OF THIS COURT that the foreclosure conducted by First Nationwide Mortgage Corporation did not violate the automatic stay provisions of
Notes
. In fact it does not appear that Debtor could carry this burden, given the potential issues related to the Statute of Frauds and the “best evidence rule,” but in light of the discussion, infra, it is unnecessary to reach that conclusion.
. In fact, the parties stipulated that the foreclosure price obtained was sufficient to pay FNMC in full and no deficiency judgment could ever arise in this case.