History
  • No items yet
midpage
Enbinder v. Commonwealth
361 Mass. 871
Mass.
1972
Check Treatment

A single justice correctly sustained a demurrer to a petition in the county court brought under G. L. c. 211, § 3, as amended by St. 1956, c. 707, § 1, to review a conviction for larceny in the Municipal Court of the City of Boston. This court, as matter of discretion, seldom will exercise the authority given to it under § 3, especially where another remedy exists. The demurrer to the petition for a writ of error, seeking review of the same conviction, is an unsatisfactory method of dealing with allegations of the type set out in the petition. As matter of discretion, the single justice appropriately should have withheld action on the demurrer until after obtaining a more complete record concerning the Municipal Court proceeding either (1) by requiring an extended return from the Municipal Court judge (cf. Southwick Birds & Animals, Inc. v. County Commrs. of *872Worcester County, 360 Mass. 133, 134, fn. 1, or (2) by taking evidence (directly or through a commissioner) concerning the Municipal Court proceeding. For the purpose of obtaining an adequate basis of fact on which to consider this matter, the order sustaining the demurrer to the petition for a writ of error is to be vacated. The case is remanded to the county court for further proceedings consistent with the views expressed above. The exception to the order with respect to the petition for relief under G. L. c. 211, § 3 (as amended), is overruled, and that petition is to be dismissed in the county court.

Sanford A. Kowal for the petitioner. James X. Kenneally, Assistant Attorney General, for the Commonwealth.

So ordered.

Case Details

Case Name: Enbinder v. Commonwealth
Court Name: Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
Date Published: Apr 3, 1972
Citation: 361 Mass. 871
Court Abbreviation: Mass.
AI-generated responses must be verified and are not legal advice.
Your Notebook is empty. To add cases, bookmark them from your search, or select Add Cases to extract citations from a PDF or a block of text.